Choi Young-Seok, Shin See-Ok
Department of Otolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery, College of Medicine, Chungbuk National University, Cheongju, Chungbuk Korea.
Indian J Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2018 Jun;70(2):184-187. doi: 10.1007/s12070-015-0952-2. Epub 2015 Dec 16.
The aim of this study is to compare the functional results and extrusion rates according to the type of ossciular alloplastic prosthesis. In this study, a retrospective analysis was performed. Sixty-one patients were involved in partial ossicular replacement (POR) cases and 70 patients were involved in total osscicular replacement (TOR) cases. In POR cases, Plastipore was used in 21 cases, hydroxyapatite in 20 cases, and titanium in 20 cases. In TOR cases, Plastipore was used in 20 cases, hydroxyapatite (HA) in 25 cases and titanium in 25 cases. We reviewed postoperative ABG (less than 20 dB or more than 20 dB) and the extrusion rate for more than 1 year follow-up period. In POR cases, ABG less than 20 dB were 71.4, 80.0, 85.0 % in plastipore, HA, and titanium prosthesis and in TOR cases, ABG less than 20 dB were 25.0, 28.0, 32.0 % in plastipore, HA, and titanium prostheses, respectively. In POR cases, extrusion rates (ER) were 9.5, 5.0, 5.0 % in plastipore, HA, and titanium prosthesis, respectively. In TOR cases, ER were 15.0, 8.0, 4.0 % in plastipore, HA, and titanium prosthesis, respectively. There were no significant differences in hearing gain results among plastipore, HA, and titanium in both POR and TOR cases, but the ER was significantly low in titanium. Clinically relatively better hearing gain and low-rate of extrusion were found in titanium prosthesis and thus this material is recommended in cases of ossicular alloplastic replacement surgery.
本研究的目的是根据听骨异体假体的类型比较其功能结果和脱出率。在本研究中,进行了回顾性分析。61例患者参与了部分听骨置换(POR)病例,70例患者参与了全听骨置换(TOR)病例。在POR病例中,21例使用了多孔聚乙烯,20例使用了羟基磷灰石,20例使用了钛。在TOR病例中,20例使用了多孔聚乙烯,25例使用了羟基磷灰石(HA),25例使用了钛。我们回顾了术后1年以上随访期的气骨导差(小于20dB或大于20dB)和脱出率。在POR病例中,多孔聚乙烯、HA和钛假体中气骨导差小于20dB的分别为71.4%、80.0%、85.0%;在TOR病例中,多孔聚乙烯、HA和钛假体中气骨导差小于20dB的分别为25.0%、28.0%、32.0%。在POR病例中,多孔聚乙烯、HA和钛假体的脱出率(ER)分别为9.5%、5.0%、5.0%。在TOR病例中,多孔聚乙烯、HA和钛假体的ER分别为15.0%、8.0%、4.0%。在POR和TOR病例中,多孔聚乙烯、HA和钛之间的听力增益结果无显著差异,但钛的ER显著较低。在钛假体中发现临床听力增益相对较好且脱出率较低,因此在听骨异体置换手术中推荐使用这种材料。