Asokkumar Ravishankar, Soetikno Roy, Sanchez-Yague Andres, Kim Wei Lim, Salazar Ennaliza, Ngu Jing Hieng
Singapore General Hospital, Singapore.
Duke Graduate School of Medicine - National University of Singapore, Singapore.
Endosc Int Open. 2018 Jul;6(7):E789-E796. doi: 10.1055/a-0614-2390. Epub 2018 Jul 4.
Endoscopic treatment of non-variceal upper gastrointestinal bleeding (NVUGIB) with high-risk adverse outcome (HR-AO) features has a high risk of failure. We studied the safety and efficacy of over-the-scope clips (OTSC) to treat these lesions.
We included patients who were treated using OTSC for NVUGIB from January 2015 to October 2017. We studied rebleeding and mortality rates and used the Rockall data and our institution's prior data for comparison. We used descriptive and chi-square statistics.
We studied 18 patients with 19 bleeding lesions: 9 (47 %) duodenal ulcers, 4 (21 %) Dieulafoy's lesion, 3 (16 %) gastric ulcer, and 3 (16 %) bleeding after gastric biopsy, gastric polypectomy and endoscopic ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration of peri-gastric mass. We applied OTSC as the first-line treatment in 10 (53 %) and as the second-line treatment in 9 (47 %) bleeding lesions. Continued bleeding after OTSC occurred in six patients, but we treated it successfully and achieved complete hemostasis in all patients. We found OTSC use significantly decreased (0 % vs. 53 %, < 0.01) and reduced (0 % vs. 24 %, = 0.08) the rebleeding rate in our high-risk (RS ≥ 8) and intermediate-risk (RS = 4 - 7) Rockall score patients as compared to the rates reported by the Rockall study, respectively. When compared to our institution's prior study, we found a decrease in the rebleeding rate with OTSC (0 % vs. 21 %, = 0.06) in our intermediate-to-high risk Rockall score patients (RS ≥ 4). There was no difference in mortality rates as compared to both control studies.
Use of OTSC is safe, efficacious and appears superior to standard treatment for HR-AO NVUGIB. OTSC should be considered as first-line treatment for HR-AO bleeding.
对具有高风险不良结局(HR - AO)特征的非静脉曲张性上消化道出血(NVUGIB)进行内镜治疗失败风险很高。我们研究了套扎式内镜夹(OTSC)治疗这些病变的安全性和有效性。
我们纳入了2015年1月至2017年10月期间使用OTSC治疗NVUGIB的患者。我们研究了再出血率和死亡率,并使用Rockall数据以及我们机构之前的数据进行比较。我们使用了描述性统计和卡方统计。
我们研究了18例患者的19处出血病变:9例(47%)为十二指肠溃疡,4例(21%)为Dieulafoy病,3例(16%)为胃溃疡,3例(16%)为胃活检、胃息肉切除及内镜超声引导下胃周肿物细针穿刺术后出血。我们将OTSC作为10处(53%)出血病变的一线治疗方法,作为9处(47%)出血病变的二线治疗方法。6例患者在使用OTSC后仍持续出血,但我们成功进行了治疗,所有患者均实现了完全止血。我们发现,与Rockall研究报告的发生率相比,在我们的高风险(Rockall评分≥8)和中风险(Rockall评分为4 - 7)患者中,使用OTSC分别显著降低了再出血率(0%对53%,P < 0.01)和减少了再出血率(0%对24%,P = 0.08)。与我们机构之前的研究相比,我们发现OTSC使中高风险Rockall评分患者(Rockall评分≥4)的再出血率降低(0%对21%,P = 0.06)。与两项对照研究相比,死亡率没有差异。
使用OTSC治疗HR - AO NVUGIB是安全、有效的,且似乎优于标准治疗。OTSC应被视为HR - AO出血的一线治疗方法。