Mackie Rose
J Law Med. 2018 Feb;25(2):503-514.
Recommendations are an increasingly important aspect of the coronial jurisdiction. This article offers one of the first critical analyses of the impact of coronial recommendations in Tasmania. In doing so, it provides a fresh perspective on coronial law from a jurisdiction that is sometimes overlooked. The article presents research (based on documentary evidence and interviews with key stakeholders) on the implementation of recommendations made by Tasmanian Chief Coroner McTaggart. The recommendations concerned unexpected infant death and youth suicide. They prompted significant reform in both areas. In view of this evidence of the power of coronial recommendations, the article argues that Tasmania should consider adopting a mandatory response framework.
建议是死因裁判管辖权中日益重要的一个方面。本文首次对塔斯马尼亚州死因裁判建议的影响进行了批判性分析。在此过程中,它从一个有时被忽视的司法管辖区为死因裁判法提供了全新视角。本文展示了关于塔斯马尼亚州首席验尸官麦塔格特所提建议实施情况的研究(基于文献证据以及对关键利益相关者的访谈)。这些建议涉及婴儿意外死亡和青少年自杀问题。它们促使这两个领域都进行了重大改革。鉴于有证据表明死因裁判建议具有影响力,本文认为塔斯马尼亚州应考虑采用一个强制性应对框架。