Li Don T, Cui Jonathan J, DeVries Stephen, Nicholson Allen D, Li Eric, Petit Logan, Kahan Joseph B, Sanders James O, Liu Raymond W, Cooperman Daniel R, Smith Brian G
Departments of Orthopaedics and Rehabilitation.
Cell Biology, Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, CT.
J Pediatr Orthop. 2018 Oct;38(9):e546-e550. doi: 10.1097/BPO.0000000000001232.
Understanding skeletal maturity is important in the management of idiopathic scoliosis. Iliac apophysis, triradiate cartilage, hand, and calcaneal ossification patterns have previously been described to assess both peak height velocity (PHV) and percent growth remaining; however, these markers may not be present on standard spine radiographs. The purpose of this study was to describe a novel maturity assessment method based on proximal humeral epiphyseal ossification patterns.
Ninety-four children were followed at least annually throughout growth with serial radiographs and physical examinations. The PHV of each child was determined by measuring the change in height observed at each visit and adjusting for the interval between visits. Percent growth remaining was determined by comparing current to final standing height. The humeral head periphyseal ossification was grouped into stages by 8 investigators ranging from medical student to attending surgeon.
The morphologic changes involving the proximal humeral physis were categorized into 5 stages based on development of the humeral head epiphysis and fusion of the lateral margin of the physis. Our novel classification scheme was well distributed around the PHV and reliably correlated with age of peak growth and percent growth remaining with >70% nonoverlapping interquartile ranges. Furthermore, the scheme was extremely reliable with intraclass correlation coefficients of 0.96 and 0.95 for intraobserver and interobserver comparisons, respectively.
The humeral head classification system described here was strongly correlated with age of PHV as well as percentage growth remaining. Furthermore, the staging system was extremely reliable in both interobserver and intraobserver correlations suggesting that it can be easily generalized.
As a view of the humeral head is almost always present on standard scoliosis spine x-ray at our institution, our classification can be easily adapted by surgeons to gain additional insight into skeletal maturity of patients with scoliosis. We believe that our method will significantly improve the evaluation of the child with scoliosis without increasing radiation exposure, time, or cost.
了解骨骼成熟度在特发性脊柱侧凸的治疗中很重要。此前已有文献描述了髂骨骨骺、三辐射软骨、手部和跟骨的骨化模式,用于评估身高生长峰值速度(PHV)和剩余生长百分比;然而,这些标志在标准脊柱X光片上可能并不存在。本研究的目的是描述一种基于肱骨近端骨骺骨化模式的新型成熟度评估方法。
对94名儿童在整个生长过程中至少每年进行一次连续的X光片检查和体格检查。通过测量每次就诊时观察到的身高变化并根据就诊间隔进行调整,来确定每个儿童的PHV。通过比较当前身高与最终身高来确定剩余生长百分比。8名研究人员(从医学生到主治外科医生)将肱骨头周围骨骺骨化分为不同阶段。
根据肱骨头骨骺的发育和骨骺外侧边缘的融合情况,将涉及肱骨近端骨骺的形态学变化分为5个阶段。我们的新型分类方案在PHV周围分布良好,并且与生长高峰期年龄和剩余生长百分比可靠相关,四分位间距的非重叠率>70%。此外,该方案具有极高的可靠性,观察者内和观察者间比较的组内相关系数分别为0.96和0.95。
这里描述的肱骨头分类系统与PHV年龄以及剩余生长百分比密切相关。此外,该分期系统在观察者间和观察者内的相关性方面都极其可靠,表明它可以很容易地推广应用。
由于在我们机构的标准脊柱侧弯X光片上几乎总能看到肱骨头,我们的分类方法外科医生可以轻松采用,以进一步了解脊柱侧弯患者的骨骼成熟度。我们相信,我们的方法将在不增加辐射暴露、时间或成本的情况下,显著改善对脊柱侧弯儿童的评估。