Kim Hye-Kyoung, Kim Mee-Eun
a Department of Oral Medicine School of Dentistry , Dankook University , Chungnam , Republic of Korea.
Somatosens Mot Res. 2018 Jun;35(2):139-147. doi: 10.1080/08990220.2018.1491837. Epub 2018 Aug 14.
Purpose/Aim: To gain a better understanding of the psychophysics of thermal pain perception in a clinical setting, this study investigated whether thermal thresholds of unpleasantness are different from pain thresholds of cold and heat stimuli. Of particular interest was the relationship between unpleasantness and pain thresholds for cold vs heat stimuli.
Thirty healthy male volunteers (mean age 26.1 years, range 23 to 32 years) participated. Thermal detection, cold pain (CPT) and heat pain (HPT) thresholds were measured at 5 trigeminal sites by the method of limits using quantitative sensory testing (QST), followed by cold unpleasant (CUT) and heat unpleasant (HUT) thresholds.
The temperatures at which individuals first reported thermal sensations as unpleasant or painful substantially differed among subjects. CUT exhibited a higher mean value with less variability than CPT, and HUT presented a lower mean than HPT (p < .001). As with CPT, CUT did not show any significant difference between the test sites. On the other hand, HUT, like HPT, exhibited site differences (p < .001). There was moderate correlation between CUT and CPT, whereas HUT and HPT were strongly correlated. The relationship between unpleasant and pain thresholds of cold vs heat stimuli was significantly different even when controlling for test site variability (p < .001).
These findings indicate that unpleasant and pain thresholds to thermal stimuli differ in healthy young men. Of particular note is the distinct relationship of unpleasant and pain thresholds of cold vs heat stimuli, revealing the thermal difference in temperature transition from unpleasantness to pain.
目的/目标:为了在临床环境中更好地理解热痛觉的心理物理学,本研究调查了不愉快的热阈值是否与冷、热刺激的疼痛阈值不同。特别感兴趣的是冷刺激与热刺激的不愉快阈值和疼痛阈值之间的关系。
30名健康男性志愿者(平均年龄26.1岁,范围23至32岁)参与研究。通过定量感觉测试(QST)的极限法在5个三叉神经部位测量热觉、冷痛(CPT)和热痛(HPT)阈值,随后测量冷不愉快(CUT)和热不愉快(HUT)阈值。
个体首次将热感觉报告为不愉快或疼痛的温度在受试者之间有很大差异。CUT的平均值较高且变异性较小,而HUT的平均值低于HPT(p <.001)。与CPT一样,CUT在测试部位之间未显示出任何显著差异。另一方面,HUT与HPT一样,存在部位差异(p <.001)。CUT与CPT之间存在中度相关性,而HUT与HPT之间存在强相关性。即使控制测试部位的变异性,冷刺激与热刺激的不愉快阈值和疼痛阈值之间的关系也存在显著差异(p <.001)。
这些发现表明,健康年轻男性对热刺激的不愉快阈值和疼痛阈值不同。特别值得注意的是冷刺激与热刺激的不愉快阈值和疼痛阈值之间的独特关系,揭示了从不愉快到疼痛的温度转变中的热差异。