Meyer Ilse S, Louw Alwyn, Ernstzen Dawn
Centre for Health Professions Education, Division of Physiotherapy, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, Stellenbosch University, South Africa.
Centre for Health Professions Education, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, Stellenbosch University, South Africa.
S Afr J Physiother. 2017 Jul 27;73(1):349. doi: 10.4102/sajp.v73i1.349. eCollection 2017.
Clinical education is widely considered to be the cornerstone of health care professionals' education. Clinical educators (CEs) fulfil many roles and act as both mentors and assessors in the learning process of students' undergraduate health care professions education. However, changing from being a mentor to being an assessor may present particular challenges for both the CE and the students.
To explore students' perceptions of how the dual role of a CE as mentor and assessor influenced the teaching-learning (T-L) relationship.
A qualitative descriptive study, involving seven individual semi-structured interviews and two focus group discussions, was conducted with students in the Division of Physiotherapy, Stellenbosch University. A contextualised interpretive content analysis was used to analyse the data. By following an iterative process, themes were identified and categories were reviewed and refined.
Challenges were experienced when CEs had to act and change as both mentors and assessors to the needs of the students. This influenced the T-L relationship and consequently impacted the learning of students. The expectations of students and CEs were often not fulfilled. Contradictions were disclosed regarding the dual role of CEs.
The findings of the study, grounded in the perceptions and experiences of students on the dual role of the CE, are highlighted. It is important to consider the challenges that the students face in order to minimise any negative effects these challenges could have on students' learning processes.
临床教育被广泛认为是医护专业人员教育的基石。临床教育工作者(CEs)在学生本科医护专业教育的学习过程中扮演多种角色,既是导师又是评估者。然而,从导师转变为评估者可能给临床教育工作者和学生都带来特殊挑战。
探讨学生对临床教育工作者作为导师和评估者的双重角色如何影响教学关系的看法。
对斯泰伦博斯大学物理治疗系的学生进行了一项定性描述性研究,包括七次个人半结构化访谈和两次焦点小组讨论。采用情境化解释性内容分析法对数据进行分析。通过迭代过程确定主题,并对类别进行审查和完善。
当临床教育工作者必须根据学生的需求同时扮演导师和评估者的角色并进行角色转换时,会遇到挑战。这影响了教学关系,进而影响了学生的学习。学生和临床教育工作者的期望往往无法实现。关于临床教育工作者的双重角色存在矛盾之处。
强调了基于学生对临床教育工作者双重角色的看法和经历得出的研究结果。考虑学生面临的挑战很重要,以便将这些挑战对学生学习过程可能产生的任何负面影响降至最低。