Kastle Hall 125, Department of Psychology, University of Kentucky, Lexington, KY, USA.
Soc Cogn Affect Neurosci. 2018 Sep 11;13(9):899-906. doi: 10.1093/scan/nsy069.
This meta-analysis (k = 48, N = 2196) examined the effect of transcranial direct current brain stimulation (tDCS) applied to the prefrontal cortex on a variety of social behaviors, including aggression, overeating, impulsivity, bias, honesty, and risk-taking. tDCS showed an overall significant effect on reducing undesirable behaviors, with an average effect size of d = -0.20. tDCS was most effective at reducing risk-taking behavior, bias, and overeating. tDCS did not affect aggression, impulsivity, or dishonesty. We examined moderators such as brain region of interest, online vs offline stimulation, within- vs between-subjects designs, dose, and duration, but none showed significant interactions. We also tested for potential publication bias using two different tools, which indicated signs of publication bias in the literature. After correcting for potential publication bias, the effect of tDCS was still significant, but the size was reduced (d = -0.10). These findings suggest the presence of tDCS studies with null findings outside of the published literature. Taken together, these results suggest that although tDCS can reduce undesirable behaviors, researchers should consider the types of behaviors they measure and use strategies to ensure sufficient power to detect a possible effect of tDCS on social behavior.
这项荟萃分析(k=48,N=2196)考察了经颅直流电刺激(tDCS)在前额叶皮层上的应用对各种社会行为的影响,包括攻击行为、暴饮暴食、冲动、偏见、诚实和冒险行为。tDCS 对减少不良行为有整体显著影响,平均效应大小为 d=-0.20。tDCS 在减少冒险行为、偏见和暴饮暴食方面最有效。tDCS 对攻击行为、冲动或不诚实行为没有影响。我们检查了诸如感兴趣的大脑区域、在线与离线刺激、被试内与被试间设计、剂量和持续时间等调节因素,但没有一个显示出显著的相互作用。我们还使用两种不同的工具测试了潜在的发表偏倚,结果表明文献中存在发表偏倚的迹象。在纠正潜在的发表偏倚后,tDCS 的效果仍然显著,但大小减小(d=-0.10)。这些发现表明,除了已发表的文献之外,可能还存在 tDCS 研究的阴性结果。综上所述,这些结果表明,尽管 tDCS 可以减少不良行为,但研究人员应考虑他们所测量的行为类型,并使用策略确保有足够的能力来检测 tDCS 对社会行为的可能影响。