Morgan Jeffrey, Crooks Valorie, Snyder Jeremy, Pickering John
Department of Geography, Simon Fraser University, British Columbia, Canada.
Faculty of Health Sciences, Simon Fraser University, British Columbia, Canada.
Can Med Educ J. 2018 Jul 27;9(3):e56-e63. eCollection 2018 Jul.
Caribbean offshore medical schools are for-profit, private institutions that provide undergraduate medical education to primarily international students, including from the United States or Canada. Despite the growing role that offshore medical schools play in training Canadian physicians, little is known about how these institutions are perceived by those in professional and decision-making positions where graduates intend to practice.
The authors interviewed 13 Canadian medical education stakeholders whose professional positions entail addressing the medical education system or physician workforce. Participants were employed in academic, governmental, and non-governmental organizations in leadership roles.
Thematic analysis revealed three cross-cutting perceptions of offshore medical schools: (a) they are at the bottom of an international hierarchy of medical schools; (b) they are heterogeneous in quality of education and student body; and (c) they have a unique business model, characterized by profit-generating and serving international students.
Consistent growth of the offshore medical school industry in the Caribbean may result in adverse reputational harms for well-established offshore or regional medical schools. Both comparative (e.g., USMLE pass rate) and intuitive factors (e.g., professional familiarity) informed participants' perceptions. Participants believed that core principles of social accountability in medical education are incompatible with the offshore medical school model.
加勒比地区的离岸医学院是营利性私立机构,主要为包括来自美国或加拿大的国际学生提供本科医学教育。尽管离岸医学院在培养加拿大医生方面发挥的作用日益增大,但对于这些机构在毕业生打算执业的专业和决策岗位人士眼中的形象,人们却知之甚少。
作者采访了13位加拿大医学教育利益相关者,他们的专业职位涉及医学教育系统或医生队伍问题。参与者受雇于学术、政府和非政府组织担任领导职务。
主题分析揭示了对离岸医学院的三种贯穿各领域的看法:(a) 它们处于国际医学院等级体系的底层;(b) 它们在教育质量和学生群体方面参差不齐;(c) 它们有独特的商业模式,其特点是盈利和服务国际学生。
加勒比地区离岸医学院行业的持续增长可能会给久负盛名的离岸或地区医学院带来负面声誉损害。比较因素(如美国医师执照考试通过率)和直观因素(如专业熟悉度)都影响了参与者的看法。参与者认为医学教育中的社会问责核心原则与离岸医学院模式不相容。