Department of Health Management and Economics, School of Public Health, International Campus, Tehran University of Medical Sciences (IC-TUMS), Tehran, Iran.
International Cooperation Directorate, Palestinian Ministry of Health, Gaza Strip, Palestine.
BMJ Open. 2018 Sep 5;8(9):e021195. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2017-021195.
Despite a high number of the internationally produced and implemented clinical guidelines, the adherence with them is still low in healthcare. This study aimed at exploring the perspectives and experiences of senior doctors and nurses towards the barriers of adherence to diabetes guideline.
The Palestinian Primary Health Care-Ministry of Health (PHC-MoH) and Primary Health Care-United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (PHC- UNRWA) in Gaza Strip.
Individual face-to-face in-depth interviews were conducted with 20 senior doctors and nurses who were purposefully selected.
Qualitative design was employed using the theoretical framework by Cabana to develop an interview guide. Semi-structural and audio-recorded interviews were conducted. Data were transcribed verbatim and thematically analysed.
The key theme barriers identified by participants that emerged from the analysed data were in regard of the PHC-MoH lack reimbursement, lack of resources and lack of the guideline trustworthiness, and in regard of PHC-UNRWA the time constraints and the lack of the guideline trustworthiness. The two key subthemes elicited from the qualitative analysis were the outdated guideline and lack of auditing and feedback.
The analysis identified a wide range of barriers against the adherence to diabetes guideline within the PHC-MoH and PHC-UNRWA. The environmental-related and guideline-related barriers were the most prominent factors influencing the guideline adherence. Our study can inform the policy makers and senior managers to develop a tailored interventions that can target the elicited barriers through a multifaceted implementation strategy.
尽管国际上制定并实施了大量临床指南,但医疗保健领域对这些指南的依从性仍然很低。本研究旨在探讨资深医生和护士对糖尿病指南依从性障碍的看法和经验。
巴勒斯坦初级卫生保健-卫生部(PHC-MoH)和初级卫生保健-联合国近东巴勒斯坦难民救济和工程处(PHC-UNRWA)在加沙地带。
采用 Cabana 理论框架有目的地选择了 20 名资深医生和护士进行个人面对面深入访谈。
采用定性设计,使用理论框架制定访谈指南。进行半结构化和录音访谈。逐字转录数据并进行主题分析。
参与者从分析数据中确定的主要主题障碍是 PHC-MoH 缺乏报销、缺乏资源和缺乏指南可信度,以及 PHC-UNRWA 的时间限制和缺乏指南可信度。从定性分析中得出的两个主要子主题是过时的指南和缺乏审计和反馈。
分析确定了 PHC-MoH 和 PHC-UNRWA 中存在广泛的糖尿病指南依从性障碍。环境相关和指南相关的障碍是影响指南依从性的最突出因素。我们的研究可以为政策制定者和高级管理人员提供信息,制定有针对性的干预措施,通过多方面的实施策略针对提出的障碍。