Neiswanger Institute for Bioethics (EE Anderson and MG Kuczewski), Department of Pediatrics (B Boyd, NK Qureshi, and JM Stirling), and University Ministry (V McCarthy), Loyola University Chicago Stritch School of Medicine, Chicago, Ill.
Neiswanger Institute for Bioethics (EE Anderson and MG Kuczewski), Department of Pediatrics (B Boyd, NK Qureshi, and JM Stirling), and University Ministry (V McCarthy), Loyola University Chicago Stritch School of Medicine, Chicago, Ill.
Acad Pediatr. 2019 Mar;19(2):170-176. doi: 10.1016/j.acap.2018.09.002. Epub 2018 Sep 7.
We assessed how third-year medical students' written reflections on home visit experiences with families of children with special needs demonstrate evidence of exposure to 9 selected competencies for pediatric clerkships designated by the Council on Medical Student Education in Pediatrics.
We reviewed written reflections from 152 third-year medical students. For each competency (2 related to communication were combined), we tabulated the number of reflections in which a given competency was demonstrated. Within each competency, themes are described and presented with exemplary quotes to provide a more robust picture of students' exposure and experience.
Of 152 reflections, 100% demonstrated at least 1 of the 8 expected competencies. Each reflection exhibited an average of 3 (3.1) competencies (range: 1-7). The competencies most frequently mentioned were demonstration of respect for patient, parent, and family attitudes, behaviors, and lifestyles (90%) and demonstration of positive attitude toward education (76%). Less frequently mentioned competencies included demonstration of behaviors and attitudes that promote patients' and families' best interests (41%), demonstration of effective verbal and nonverbal communication skills (a combination of 2 communication-related competencies) (33%), and description of barriers that prevent children from accessing health care (37%). The following competencies were least often mentioned: description of a pediatrician's role and responsibility in advocating for patients' needs (10%), description of the important role of patient education (8%), or description of the types of problems that benefit from a community approach (17%).
Our analysis demonstrates that community-based home visits can provide medical students with opportunities to meet required pediatric clerkship competencies.
我们评估了三年级医学生在家庭访视特殊需求儿童家庭时的书面反思,以证明其接触儿科学学生教育理事会指定的 9 项儿科实习必备能力的情况。
我们对 152 名三年级医学生的书面反思进行了回顾。对于每个能力(2 项与沟通相关的能力合并),我们统计了在给定能力中有多少反思。在每个能力中,都描述了主题并提供了示例引语,以更全面地了解学生的接触和经验。
在 152 份反思中,100%的反思至少展示了 8 项预期能力中的 1 项。每份反思平均展示了 3(3.1)项能力(范围:1-7)。最常提到的能力包括对患者、家长和家庭的态度、行为和生活方式表示尊重(90%)和对教育表现出积极的态度(76%)。较少提及的能力包括表现出促进患者和家庭最佳利益的行为和态度(41%)、表现出有效的言语和非言语沟通技巧(2 项与沟通相关的能力的组合)(33%)以及描述阻碍儿童获得医疗保健的障碍(37%)。以下能力很少被提及:描述儿科医生在倡导患者需求方面的角色和责任(10%)、描述患者教育的重要作用(8%)或描述受益于社区方法的问题类型(17%)。
我们的分析表明,基于社区的家访可以为医学生提供接触儿科实习必备能力的机会。