Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, University of California, Irvine, CA 92697-2525
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2018 Sep 25;115(39):9803-9806. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1809787115. Epub 2018 Sep 10.
The universal law of generalization describes how animals discriminate between alternative sensory stimuli. On an appropriate perceptual scale, the probability that an organism perceives two stimuli as similar typically declines exponentially with the difference on the perceptual scale. Exceptions often follow a Gaussian probability pattern rather than an exponential pattern. Previous explanations have been based on underlying theoretical frameworks such as information theory, Kolmogorov complexity, or empirical multidimensional scaling. This article shows that the few inevitable invariances that must apply to any reasonable perceptual scale provide a sufficient explanation for the universal exponential law of generalization. In particular, reasonable measurement scales of perception must be invariant to shift by a constant value, which by itself leads to the exponential form. Similarly, reasonable measurement scales of perception must be invariant to multiplication, or stretch, by a constant value, which leads to the conservation of the slope of discrimination with perceptual difference. In some cases, an additional assumption about exchangeability or rotation of underlying perceptual dimensions leads to a Gaussian pattern of discrimination, which can be understood as a special case of the more general exponential form. The three measurement invariances of shift, stretch, and rotation provide a sufficient explanation for the universally observed patterns of perceptual generalization. All of the additional assumptions and language associated with information, complexity, and empirical scaling are superfluous with regard to the broad patterns of perception.
普遍概括定律描述了动物如何区分不同的感觉刺激。在适当的感知尺度上,生物感知两种刺激相似的概率通常会随感知尺度上的差异呈指数下降。例外情况通常遵循高斯概率模式而不是指数模式。以前的解释基于信息论、柯尔莫哥洛夫复杂性或经验多维标度等基础理论框架。本文表明,任何合理的感知尺度都必须适用的少数必然不变性为普遍的概括指数定律提供了充分的解释。特别是,合理的感知测量尺度必须对常数值的偏移保持不变,这本身就导致了指数形式。同样,合理的感知测量尺度必须对常数值的乘法或拉伸保持不变,这导致了与感知差异的判别斜率的守恒。在某些情况下,关于潜在感知维度的可交换性或旋转的额外假设导致了判别呈高斯模式,可以将其理解为更普遍的指数形式的特殊情况。偏移、拉伸和旋转这三个测量不变性为普遍观察到的感知概括模式提供了充分的解释。关于信息、复杂性和经验标度的所有额外假设和语言都与感知的广泛模式无关。