Ihde D C, Deisseroth A B, Lichter A S, Bunn P A, Carney D N, Cohen M H, Veach S R, Makuch R W, Johnston-Early A, Abrams R A
J Clin Oncol. 1986 Oct;4(10):1443-54. doi: 10.1200/JCO.1986.4.10.1443.
To attempt to improve the poor prognosis of extensive-stage small-cell lung cancer (SCLC) patients, we tried to administer late intensive combined modality therapy (LICMRX) to patients with good tumor regression after 12 weeks of conventional chemotherapy. Twenty-nine consecutive extensive-stage SCLC patients received 6 weeks of cyclophosphamide, methotrexate, and lomustine (CMC) induction therapy, followed by 6 weeks of vincristine, doxorubicin, and procarbazine (VAP). After restaging for assessment of tumor response, autologous bone marrow (ABM) was collected in patients in good medical condition with complete response (CR) or partial response (PR) and no tumor on marrow examination. LICMRX consisted of irradiation with 2,000 rad in five fractions for five days to sites of initial tumor involvement, followed by cyclophosphamide, 60 mg/kg for 2 days, and etoposide, 200 mg/m2 for 3 days and then by ABM infusion. Prophylactic cranial irradiation (PCI) was administered thereafter, but no further chemotherapy was used. Due to lack of tumor regression or poor medical condition, only ten of the original 29 patients were eligible for LICMRX; two refused, so only eight (28%) received therapy. Three patients who began LICMRX in CR developed recurrence of SCLC after an additional 4, 8, and 15 months. Of five patients with PR, one attained CR but relapsed at 3 months, two remained in PR and progressed at 2 and 4 months, and two died of infection without recovery from LICMRX. Mean time from ABM infusion to recovery of granulocyte count to 500/microL was 15.8 days in the six surviving patients (range, 12-22). The major non-hematologic toxicity of LICMRX was severe esophagitis. Among all 29 patients, there were six CRs (21%) and no 2-year survivors, compared with a CR rate of 36% and 10% 2-year survivors in 78 extensive-stage patients previously treated with CMC plus VAP without LICMRX. We conclude that the LICMRX given in this study can be administered to only a minority of extensive-stage SCLC patients and is very unlikely to yield substantial improvement in the fraction of 2-year survivors (95% confidence limits for 2-year survival 0% to 10%).
为改善广泛期小细胞肺癌(SCLC)患者的不良预后,我们尝试对接受12周常规化疗后肿瘤显著消退的患者进行晚期强化联合模式治疗(LICMRX)。连续29例广泛期SCLC患者接受6周的环磷酰胺、甲氨蝶呤和洛莫司汀(CMC)诱导治疗,随后接受6周的长春新碱、多柔比星和丙卡巴肼(VAP)治疗。重新分期以评估肿瘤反应后,对身体状况良好、达到完全缓解(CR)或部分缓解(PR)且骨髓检查无肿瘤的患者采集自体骨髓(ABM)。LICMRX包括对初始肿瘤累及部位进行5天、分5次给予2000拉德的照射,随后给予环磷酰胺,60mg/kg,共2天,依托泊苷,200mg/m²,共3天,然后进行ABM输注。此后给予预防性颅脑照射(PCI),但不再使用进一步的化疗。由于缺乏肿瘤消退或身体状况不佳,最初的29例患者中只有10例符合LICMRX治疗条件;2例拒绝,因此只有8例(28%)接受了治疗。3例在CR状态下开始LICMRX治疗的患者在另外4、8和15个月后出现SCLC复发。5例PR患者中,1例达到CR但在3个月时复发,2例维持PR状态并在2个月和4个月时病情进展,2例死于感染,未从LICMRX治疗中恢复。6例存活患者从ABM输注到粒细胞计数恢复至500/μL的平均时间为15.8天(范围为12 - 22天)。LICMRX的主要非血液学毒性是严重食管炎。在所有29例患者中,有6例CR(21%),无2年存活者,而在先前接受CMC加VAP但未接受LICMRX治疗的78例广泛期患者中,CR率为36%,2年存活者为10%。我们得出结论,本研究中给予的LICMRX仅适用于少数广泛期SCLC患者,极不可能在2年存活者比例上取得实质性改善(2年生存率的95%置信区间为0%至10%)。