Department of Psychology, The University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois.
Department of Psychology, The University of Wisconsin Green Bay, Green Bay, Wisconsin.
Dev Sci. 2019 Mar;22(2):e12729. doi: 10.1111/desc.12729. Epub 2018 Sep 12.
A concern for fairness is a fundamental and universal element of morality. To examine the extent to which cultural norms are integrated into fairness cognitions and influence social preferences regarding equality and equity, a large sample of children (N 2,163) aged 4-11 were tested in 13 diverse countries. Children participated in three versions of a third-party, contextualized distributive justice game between two hypothetical recipients differing in terms of wealth, merit, and empathy. Social decision-making in these games revealed universal age-related shifts from equality-based to equity-based distribution motivations across cultures. However, differences in levels of individualism and collectivism between the 13 countries predicted the age and extent to which children favor equity in each condition. Children from the most individualistic cultures endorsed equitable distributions to a greater degree than children from more collectivist cultures when recipients differed in regards to wealth and merit. However, in an empathy context where recipients differed in injury, children from the most collectivist cultures exhibited greater preferences to distribute resource equitably compared to children from more individualistic cultures. Children from the more individualistic cultures also favored equitable distributions at an earlier age than children from more collectivist cultures overall. These results demonstrate aspects of both cross-cultural similarity and divergence in the development of fairness preferences.
对公平的关注是道德的一个基本和普遍的要素。为了研究文化规范在多大程度上融入了公平认知,并影响了人们对平等和公平的社会偏好,我们在 13 个不同国家测试了大量 4 至 11 岁的儿童(N2,163)。儿童参与了三个版本的第三方情境分配正义游戏,游戏涉及两个假设的接受者,他们在财富、优点和同理心方面存在差异。这些游戏中的社会决策揭示了普遍存在的、与年龄相关的从基于平等到基于公平的分配动机转变,这种转变跨越了不同的文化。然而,13 个国家之间的个人主义和集体主义水平的差异预测了儿童在每种情况下对公平的偏好的年龄和程度。在财富和优点不同的情况下,来自最个人主义文化的儿童比来自更集体主义文化的儿童更倾向于公平分配。然而,在涉及伤害的同理心情境中,与来自更个人主义文化的儿童相比,来自更集体主义文化的儿童表现出更大的分配资源公平的偏好。来自更个人主义文化的儿童也比来自更集体主义文化的儿童更早地倾向于公平分配。这些结果表明,公平偏好的发展存在跨文化的相似性和差异。