Massey Garry J, Balshaw Thomas G, Maden-Wilkinson Thomas M, Tillin Neale A, Folland Jonathan P
Arthritis Research UK Centre for Sport, Exercise and Osteoarthritis, Loughborough University, Loughborough, United Kingdom.
School of Sport, Exercise, and Health Sciences, Loughborough University, Loughborough, United Kingdom.
Front Physiol. 2018 Sep 4;9:1170. doi: 10.3389/fphys.2018.01170. eCollection 2018.
The effect of different strength training regimes, and in particular training utilizing brief explosive contractions, on tendinous tissue properties is poorly understood. This study compared the efficacy of 12 weeks of knee extensor explosive-contraction (ECT; = 14) vs. sustained-contraction (SCT; = 15) strength training vs. a non-training control ( = 13) to induce changes in patellar tendon and knee extensor tendon-aponeurosis stiffness and size (patellar tendon, vastus-lateralis aponeurosis, quadriceps femoris muscle) in healthy young men. Training involved 40 isometric knee extension contractions (three times/week): gradually increasing to 75% of maximum voluntary torque (MVT) before holding for 3 s (SCT), or briefly contracting as fast as possible to ∼80% MVT (ECT). Changes in patellar tendon stiffness and Young's modulus, tendon-aponeurosis complex stiffness, as well as quadriceps femoris muscle volume, vastus-lateralis aponeurosis area and patellar tendon cross-sectional area were quantified with ultrasonography, dynamometry, and magnetic resonance imaging. ECT and SCT similarly increased patellar tendon stiffness (20% vs. 16%, both < 0.05 vs. control) and Young's modulus (22% vs. 16%, both < 0.05 vs. control). Tendon-aponeurosis complex high-force stiffness increased only after SCT (21%; < 0.02), while ECT resulted in greater overall elongation of the tendon-aponeurosis complex. Quadriceps muscle volume only increased after sustained-contraction training (8%; = 0.001), with unclear effects of strength training on aponeurosis area. The changes in patellar tendon cross-sectional area after strength training were not appreciably different to control. Our results suggest brief high force muscle contractions can induce increased free tendon stiffness, though SCT is needed to increase tendon-aponeurosis complex stiffness and muscle hypertrophy.
不同强度训练方案,尤其是利用短暂爆发性收缩的训练对肌腱组织特性的影响,目前了解甚少。本研究比较了12周的膝关节伸肌爆发性收缩训练(ECT;n = 14)与持续收缩训练(SCT;n = 15)以及非训练对照组(n = 13)对健康年轻男性髌腱和膝关节伸肌腱膜刚度及大小(髌腱、股外侧肌腱膜、股四头肌)的影响。训练包括40次等长膝关节伸展收缩(每周3次):在保持3秒前逐渐增加到最大自主扭矩(MVT)的75%(SCT),或尽可能快地短暂收缩至约80%MVT(ECT)。通过超声检查、测力计和磁共振成像对髌腱刚度和杨氏模量、腱膜复合体刚度以及股四头肌体积、股外侧肌腱膜面积和髌腱横截面积的变化进行量化。ECT和SCT同样增加了髌腱刚度(分别为20%和16%,两者与对照组相比P均<0.05)和杨氏模量(分别为22%和16%,两者与对照组相比P均<0.05)。腱膜复合体高力刚度仅在SCT后增加(21%;P<0.02),而ECT导致腱膜复合体的总体伸长更大。股四头肌体积仅在持续收缩训练后增加(8%;P = 0.001),力量训练对腱膜面积的影响尚不清楚。力量训练后髌腱横截面积的变化与对照组无明显差异。我们的结果表明,短暂的高强度肌肉收缩可导致游离肌腱刚度增加,不过需要SCT来增加腱膜复合体刚度和肌肉肥大。