Beyer Christian
Philosophisches Seminar, Georg-August-Universität Göttingen, Göttingen, Germany.
Front Psychol. 2018 Sep 7;9:1628. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2018.01628. eCollection 2018.
The paper presents and defends a metadoxastic view on (intentional) consciousness that is novel in four respects: (1) It is motivated both by Husserl's dynamic approach, which looks upon mental acts as momentary components of certain cognitive structures - "dynamic intentional structures" - in which one and the same object is intended throughout a period of time (during which the subject's cognitive perspective upon that object is constantly changing) and by his conception of consciousness in terms of internal time-consciousness (temporal awareness). (2) It combines a dispositionalist higher-order judgment theory about the structure of (intentional) consciousness with the claim that the contents of these judgments are such that they can be expressed by essentially indexical sentences containing the temporal indexical "now," thus accommodating the basic role of internal time-consciousness. (3) It is immune against the "objection from lack of mental concepts" raised, e.g., by Dretske against any higher-order representation theory, as it employs counterfactuals in the framework of a disjunctive account of (intentional) consciousness. (4) It explains the unity of consciousness at a time as well as across time.
本文提出并捍卫了一种关于(意向性)意识的元信念观点,该观点在四个方面具有新颖性:(1)它既受到胡塞尔动态进路的推动,该进路将心理行为视为某些认知结构——“动态意向结构”——的瞬间组成部分,在这些结构中,同一个对象在一段时间内被意向(在此期间,主体对该对象的认知视角不断变化),又受到他从内在时间意识(时间觉知)角度对意识的构想的推动。(2)它将关于(意向性)意识结构的一种倾向主义高阶判断理论与这样一种主张相结合,即这些判断的内容能够由包含时间索引词“现在”的基本索引句来表达,从而适应了内在时间意识的基本作用。(3)它能够抵御例如德雷茨克针对任何高阶表征理论提出的“缺乏心理概念的反对意见”,因为它在对(意向性)意识的析取式解释框架中运用了反事实条件句。(4)它解释了意识在某一时刻以及跨时间的统一性。