Holoyda Brian James
Department of Psychiatry & Behavioral Neuroscience, Saint Louis University School of Medicine, St Louis, MO, USA.
Behav Sci Law. 2018 Nov;36(6):675-686. doi: 10.1002/bsl.2367. Epub 2018 Sep 24.
Animals have long formed an important part of human communities and served various roles in human activities. Some of the earliest human civilizations developed laws that protected animals for assorted reasons, including their economic value, religious beliefs pertaining to animals, and societal concerns about cleanliness. In the 1800s, Western thinkers began to view animals as having rights of their own and proposed legislation that changed the legal landscape regarding animal maltreatment. In the United States today there are widely varying laws designed to address the various forms of animal maltreatment. Each state's laws are different. Some states have modern statutes designed to identify and punish animal maltreatment, and others are relatively lax in their consideration of what constitutes abuse. The purpose of this article is to review the development of animal maltreatment legislation from ancient civilization to the present day in the United States; to identify current legislative reforms designed to assist in investigating and prosecuting animal abusers; to describe the role that forensic mental health experts may play in evaluating abusers for a variety of related concerns, including violence risk, sexual violence risk, and fitness for guardianship of an animal; and to delineate areas requiring further research to improve the forensic evaluation of animal abusers.
长期以来,动物一直是人类社会的重要组成部分,并在人类活动中发挥着各种作用。一些最早的人类文明制定了法律来保护动物,原因多种多样,包括动物的经济价值、与动物相关的宗教信仰以及社会对清洁的关注。在19世纪,西方思想家开始认为动物拥有自身权利,并提出了改变虐待动物相关法律格局的立法。如今在美国,有各种各样旨在应对各种形式虐待动物行为的法律。每个州的法律都不同。一些州有旨在识别和惩罚虐待动物行为的现代法规,而其他州在考虑什么构成虐待方面则相对宽松。本文的目的是回顾美国从古代文明到当今虐待动物立法的发展;确定当前旨在协助调查和起诉虐待动物者的立法改革;描述法医心理健康专家在评估虐待动物者时可能在各种相关问题上发挥的作用,包括暴力风险、性暴力风险以及照顾动物的适宜性;并勾勒出需要进一步研究以改进对虐待动物者法医评估的领域。