Department of Medicine I (Specialties: Hematology, Oncology, and Stem-Cell Transplantation), Faculty of Medicine, Medical Center - University of Freiburg, Hugstetterstr. 55, 79106, Freiburg, Germany.
Institute for Exercise- and Occupational Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Medical Center - University of Freiburg, Freiburg, Germany.
BMC Cancer. 2018 Sep 25;18(1):920. doi: 10.1186/s12885-018-4813-8.
Hospitalized cancer patients undergoing intensive or high-dose chemotherapy often experience a considerable decline in functional performance associated with the increased risk of adverse health events. Exercises, particularly resistance-based exercises that may counteract this decline are restricted by therapy-related side effects. Since whole body vibration (WBV) is known to efficiently stimulate the neuromuscular system without significantly raising blood pressure, we hypothesize that especially WBV is particularly feasible even during intensive or high-dose chemotherapy (primary endpoint) and thus induces beneficial functional adaptations.
Twenty hospitalized patients with hematological malignancies scheduled for intensive or high-dose chemotherapy were randomly allocated to an intervention group (IG) undergoing WBV, or an active control group (CG) cycling. Feasibility was determined by comparing the IG's and CG's training compliance. Furthermore, to assess feasibility, WBV-induced changes in chemotherapy-related side effects, blood pressure, and heart rate immediately after exercising were documented. To assess patients' functional performance, we measured jump height (cm), the duration (sec) of performing the chair rising- (CRT) and timed-up-and-go test (TUG), maximum power output during jumping and CRT (watt/kg) as well as sway path (mm) during balance tasks.
Training compliance was similar between groups (IG: median 62%, range 39-77; CG: 67%, 58-100; p = 0.315). Moreover, we observed neither the IG's reported side effects worsening, nor any increase in blood pressure after WBV. IG's jump height (+ 2.3 cm, 95%CI 0.1-4.4, p = 0.028) and TUG performance (- 1.3 s, 95%CI -2.53 - -0.65, p = 0.027) improved significantly, while sway paths in semi-tandem stance were augmented after the intervention (eyes open: + 60 mm, 95%CI 2-236, p = 0.046; eyes closed: + 88 mm, 95%CI 49-214, p = 0.028). The CG's performances did not change over time. Maximum power output during CMJ and CRT and time during CRT did not change.
Our study is the first proving the feasibility of WBV during intensive/high-dose chemotherapy of hospitalized cancer patients. Additionally, WBV-induced neuromuscular adaptations resulted in functional benefits relevant to patients' autonomy. We believe that WBV can be implemented as an alternative training method during intensive chemotherapy, although the relative benefit compared to conventional resistance training requires more evaluation in future studies.
German Register of Clinical Trials No.: DRKS00004338 , prospectively registered on 11/30/2012.
接受强化或大剂量化疗的住院癌症患者的功能表现通常会显著下降,这与不良健康事件的风险增加有关。锻炼,特别是可能对抗这种下降的基于阻力的锻炼,受到治疗相关副作用的限制。由于全身振动(WBV)已知可有效地刺激神经肌肉系统而不会显著升高血压,因此我们假设,特别是 WBV 在强化或大剂量化疗期间特别可行(主要终点),从而引起有益的功能适应。
20 名计划接受强化或大剂量化疗的血液恶性肿瘤住院患者被随机分配到接受全身振动(WBV)的干预组(IG)或进行主动控制组(CG)循环运动。通过比较 IG 和 CG 的训练依从性来确定可行性。此外,为了评估可行性,记录了 WBV 后化疗相关副作用、血压和心率的即刻变化。为了评估患者的功能表现,我们测量了跳跃高度(cm)、椅子上升测试(CRT)和计时起立行走测试(TUG)的持续时间(sec)、跳跃和 CRT 时的最大功率输出(watt/kg)以及平衡任务时的摆动路径(mm)。
两组的训练依从性相似(IG:中位数 62%,范围 39-77;CG:67%,58-100;p=0.315)。此外,我们既没有观察到 IG 报告的副作用恶化,也没有观察到 WBV 后血压升高。IG 的跳跃高度(+2.3cm,95%CI 0.1-4.4,p=0.028)和 TUG 表现(-1.3s,95%CI -2.53- -0.65,p=0.027)显著改善,而半串联姿势下的摆动路径在干预后增加(睁眼:+60mm,95%CI 2-236,p=0.046;闭眼:+88mm,95%CI 49-214,p=0.028)。CG 的表现随时间没有变化。CMJ 和 CRT 时的最大功率输出以及 CRT 时间没有变化。
我们的研究首次证明了在住院癌症患者强化/大剂量化疗期间进行 WBV 的可行性。此外,WBV 诱导的神经肌肉适应性导致了与患者自主性相关的功能益处。我们相信,WBV 可以作为强化化疗期间的替代训练方法实施,尽管与传统阻力训练相比,其相对益处需要在未来的研究中进行更多评估。
德国临床试验注册处编号:DRKS00004338,于 2012 年 11 月 30 日进行前瞻性注册。