Schold S C, Mahaley M S, Vick N A, Friedman H S, Burger P C, DeLong E R, Albright R E, Bullard D E, Khandekar J D, Cairncross J G
J Clin Oncol. 1987 Mar;5(3):464-71. doi: 10.1200/JCO.1987.5.3.464.
We treated 103 patients with histologically confirmed anaplastic supratentorial astrocytic neoplasms with either diaziquone (AZQ) and carmustine (BCNU) or AZQ and procarbazine. There were 74 patients with glioblastoma multiforme (GBM) and 29 patients with anaplastic astrocytoma (AA). AZQ plus BCNU produced partial (PR) or unequivocal responses in seven of 32 (21.9%) patients with GBMs and three of ten (30%) patients with AAs. Two patients with GBMs (6.3%) and five patients with AAs (50%) showed stable disease (SD). AZQ plus procarbazine produced PRs or unequivocal responses in five of 42 (11.9%) patients with GBMs and nine of 19 (47.4%) patients with AAs. Eight patients with GBMs (19%) and one patient with an AA (5.2%) showed SD. In addition to histologic diagnosis, only the Karnofsky performance-status (KPS) rating independently influenced response and survival. Differences in response rates between the two regimens were not significant, although estimated median survival after adjusting for performance status was slightly better with AZQ plus BCNU than with AZQ plus procarbazine (P = .031). Neither age nor prior chemotherapy were significant independent risk factors. Toxicity was mild and primarily hematologic. We conclude that these AZQ-based regimens have activity in patients with recurrent anaplastic gliomas, but that they are not clearly superior to other agents in current use. The histologic diagnosis of GBM is associated with a significantly worse prognosis than AA, and we believe that this important distinction must be recognized in phase II as well as phase III trials.
我们用重氮喹酮(AZQ)与卡莫司汀(BCNU)或AZQ与丙卡巴肼治疗了103例经组织学确诊的幕上间变性星形细胞瘤患者。其中有74例多形性胶质母细胞瘤(GBM)患者和29例间变性星形细胞瘤(AA)患者。AZQ加BCNU使32例GBM患者中的7例(21.9%)和10例AA患者中的3例(30%)产生部分缓解(PR)或明确缓解。2例GBM患者(6.3%)和5例AA患者(50%)病情稳定(SD)。AZQ加丙卡巴肼使42例GBM患者中的5例(11.9%)和19例AA患者中的9例(47.4%)产生PR或明确缓解。8例GBM患者(19%)和1例AA患者(5.2%)病情稳定。除组织学诊断外,只有卡诺夫斯基功能状态(KPS)评分独立影响缓解和生存情况。两种治疗方案的缓解率差异不显著,尽管校正功能状态后的估计中位生存期AZQ加BCNU略优于AZQ加丙卡巴肼(P = 0.031)。年龄和既往化疗均不是显著的独立危险因素。毒性较轻,主要为血液学毒性。我们得出结论,这些基于AZQ的治疗方案对复发性间变性胶质瘤患者有活性,但并不明显优于目前使用的其他药物。GBM的组织学诊断与比AA明显更差的预后相关,我们认为这一重要区别在II期和III期试验中都必须得到认识。