Moon Myung-Sang, Kim Sang-Jae, Kim Min-Su, Kim Dong-Suk
Department of Orthopedic Surgery and Traumatology, Cheju Halla General Hospital, Jeju, Korea.
Asian Spine J. 2018 Dec;12(6):1069-1077. doi: 10.31616/asj.2018.12.6.1069. Epub 2018 Oct 16.
A case study.
To assess the chronological changes of the disease-related kyphosis after chemotherapy alone, secondly to clarify the role of growth cartilage in the healed lesion on kyphosis change, and to define the accurate prediction time in assessing residual kyphosis.
None of the previous papers up to now dealt with the residual kyphosis, stability and remodeling processes of the affected segments.
One hundred and one spinal tuberculosis children with various stages of disease processes, age 2 to 15 years, were the subject materials, between 1971 to 2010. They were treated with two different chemotherapy formula: before 1975, 18 months of triple chemotherapy (isoniazid [INH], para-aminosalicylic acid, streptomycin); and since 1976, 12 months triple chemotherapy (INH, rifampicin, ethambutol, or pyrazinamide). The first assessment at post-chemotherapy one year and at the final discharge time from the follow-up (36 months at minimum and 20 years at maximum) were analyzed by utilizing the images effect of the remaining growth plate cartilage on chronological changes of kyphosis after initiation of chemotherapy.
Complete disc destruction at the initial examination were observed in two (5.0%) out of 40 cervical spine, eight (26.7%) out of 30 dorsal spine, and six (19.4%) out of 31 lumbosacral spine. In all those cases residual kyphosis developed inevitably. In the remainders the discs were partially preserved or remained intact. Among 101 children kyphosis was maintained without change in 20 (19.8%), while kyphosis decreased in 14 children (13.7%), and increased in 67 children (66.3%) with non-recoverably damaged growth plate, respectively.
It could tentatively be possible to predict the deformity progress or non-progress and spontaneous correction at the time of initial treatment, but it predictive accuracy was low. Therefore, assessment of the trend of kyphotic change is recommended at the end of chemotherapy. In children with progressive curve change, the deformity assessment should be continued till the maturity.
一项病例研究。
评估单纯化疗后疾病相关驼背的时间变化,其次阐明生长软骨在愈合病变中对驼背变化的作用,并确定评估残留驼背的准确预测时间。
迄今为止,以前的论文均未涉及受影响节段的残留驼背、稳定性和重塑过程。
选取1971年至2010年间101例年龄在2至15岁、处于疾病不同阶段的脊柱结核儿童作为研究对象。他们接受了两种不同的化疗方案:1975年以前,采用18个月的三联化疗(异烟肼[INH]、对氨基水杨酸、链霉素);1976年起,采用12个月的三联化疗(INH、利福平、乙胺丁醇或吡嗪酰胺)。利用剩余生长板软骨的影像效应,分析化疗后一年及随访最终出院时(最短36个月,最长20年)驼背的时间变化。
在40例颈椎病例中,初始检查时观察到2例(5.0%)椎间盘完全破坏;30例胸椎病例中,8例(26.7%);31例腰骶椎病例中,6例(19.4%)。在所有这些病例中,不可避免地出现了残留驼背。其余病例中,椎间盘部分保留或保持完整。在101例儿童中,20例(19.8%)驼背无变化,14例儿童(13.7%)驼背减轻,67例儿童(66.3%)生长板严重受损导致驼背增加。
在初始治疗时初步预测畸形进展或无进展及自发矫正具有一定可能性,但预测准确性较低。因此,建议在化疗结束时评估驼背变化趋势。对于驼背曲线呈进展性变化的儿童,应持续进行畸形评估直至成熟。