Fournier Clément, Dhalluin Xavier, Wallyn Frederic, Machuron François, Bouchindhomme Brigitte, Copin Marie C, Valentin Victor
CHU Lille, Bronchoscopy Department, Calmette Hospital.
CHU Lille, Biostatistic Department.
J Bronchology Interv Pulmonol. 2019 Jul;26(3):193-198. doi: 10.1097/LBR.0000000000000551.
Little data exists regarding the performance of elastography in EBUS-TBNA. The aim of the study was to evaluate the elastography score proposed and previously published by Izumo, in particular its capacity to perfectly identify benign lymph node, and to discriminate malignant ones.
This study included patients undergoing EBUS-TBNA for mediastinal lymph nodes (LN). Before LN needle aspiration, an elastography was performed which allowed a color elastogram to be superimposed on the ultrasound image. Three blinded assessors classified these elastograms into 3 types using the score published by Izumo: type 1 (predominantly not blue), type 2 (partially blue, partially not blue), or type 3 (predominantly blue). These types were then compared with pathology results.
A total of 217 LN (114 patients) were analyzed: histologic findings identified 97 benign LN (44.7% of the lymph nodes) and 120 malignant LN (55.3%). There were 44 elastographies (20.2%) that were classified as type 1, 90 elastographies (41.5%) classified as type 2, and 83 elastographies (38.3%) classified as type 3. Considering type 1 as benign and type 3 as malignant, sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value were respectively 87.0%, 68.0% , 80.0% , and 77.0%. Ten (23%) of the 44 lymph nodes with a type 1 elastogram were malignant.
Elastography does not preclude performing TBNA of the lymph nodes. It does not preclude EBUS-TBNA when a type 1 elastogram pattern is found. All lymph nodes visualized should be sampled by EBUS-TBNA, regardless of elastography pattern.
关于超声弹性成像在超声内镜引导下经支气管针吸活检术(EBUS-TBNA)中的表现,现有数据较少。本研究的目的是评估由出云提出并先前发表的弹性成像评分,特别是其完美识别良性淋巴结以及鉴别恶性淋巴结的能力。
本研究纳入了接受EBUS-TBNA检查纵隔淋巴结(LN)的患者。在对LN进行针吸之前,先进行弹性成像,使彩色弹性图叠加在超声图像上。三名盲法评估者使用出云发表的评分将这些弹性图分为3种类型:1型(主要非蓝色)、2型(部分蓝色,部分非蓝色)或3型(主要为蓝色)。然后将这些类型与病理结果进行比较。
共分析了217个LN(114例患者):组织学检查发现97个良性LN(占淋巴结的44.7%)和120个恶性LN(占55.3%)。有44个弹性成像(20.2%)被分类为1型,90个弹性成像(41.5%)被分类为2型,83个弹性成像(38.3%)被分类为3型。将1型视为良性,3型视为恶性,敏感性、特异性、阳性预测值和阴性预测值分别为87.0%、68.0%、80.0%和77.0%。44个1型弹性图的LN中有10个(23%)为恶性。
弹性成像并不妨碍对淋巴结进行TBNA。当发现1型弹性图模式时,并不妨碍进行EBUS-TBNA。无论弹性成像模式如何,所有可视化的淋巴结均应通过EBUS-TBNA进行采样。