Tabak Sahar A, Khalifa Sara E, Fathy Yasmine
Pathology Department, Faculty of Medicine, Cairo University, Cairo, Egypt.
Open Access Maced J Med Sci. 2018 Sep 4;6(9):1555-1560. doi: 10.3889/oamjms.2018.318. eCollection 2018 Sep 25.
Osteosarcoma and chondrosarcoma, remain the most common primary bone tumours. Questions have been raised about the prognostic influence of HER-2 in bone sarcomas, but so far the results have been debatable. The her-2 expression is possibly a predictor of chemotherapy response.
In this study, we investigated the extent of HER-2 expression in bone sarcomas, and attempted to correlate it with pertinent variables that will help to provide better treatment options, especially for metastatic ones.
Fifty-two cases of bone sarcomas (32 osteosarcoma cases and 20 chondrosarcoma ones) were studied for HER-2 immunohistochemical expression then correlation with all available clinicopathologic features was done.
Most of the osteosarcoma cases exhibited membranous staining (78.1%). Strong staining was observed (score 3+) in 34.4%; while 21.9% showed moderate staining (score 2+); and 21.9% displayed weak staining (score 1+), on the other hand, no staining was detected in 7 out of 32 cases (21.9%) (score 0). As regards chondrosarcoma, the absence of staining in all examined cases was noted. Immunohistochemical HER-2 overexpression correlated significantly with osteosarcoma site with P value = 0.004, with variation relating HER-2 intensity score to the site of osteosarcoma (P = 0.051). A statistically significant negative correlation was detected between HER-2 expression and the presence of metastasis at time of diagnosis (P = 0.006), A significant correlation was also found regarding HER-2 score and presence of metastasis with P value = 0.046 as more than half of cases with no metastasis at diagnosis (17/28 cases, 60.7%) showed positive intensity score. A statistically significant correlation was detected between HER-2 expression and patients' age (P = 0.044). Also, HER-2 expression significantly correlated to histopathological detection of fibrous tissue, with P value = 0.033. Higher scores of HER-2 expression were associated with a significantly better differentiation (P = 0.038) since detection of wide areas of osteoid were associated with higher HER-2 scores.
Further research would still be needed to delineate HER-2 role being a new hope for therapeutic targeting in bone sarcoma patients, mainly osteosarcoma in contrast to chondrosarcoma that didn't express HER-2 at all.
骨肉瘤和软骨肉瘤仍然是最常见的原发性骨肿瘤。关于HER-2在骨肉瘤中的预后影响存在疑问,但迄今为止结果仍有争议。HER-2表达可能是化疗反应的一个预测指标。
在本研究中,我们调查了骨肉瘤中HER-2的表达程度,并试图将其与相关变量进行关联,以帮助提供更好的治疗选择,尤其是对于转移性骨肉瘤。
对52例骨肉瘤(32例骨肉瘤和20例软骨肉瘤)进行HER-2免疫组化表达研究,然后将其与所有可用的临床病理特征进行关联。
大多数骨肉瘤病例表现为膜性染色(78.1%)。34.4%观察到强染色(评分3+);21.9%表现为中度染色(评分2+);21.9%显示弱染色(评分1+),另一方面,32例中有7例(21.9%)未检测到染色(评分0)。至于软骨肉瘤,在所有检查病例中均未观察到染色。免疫组化HER-2过表达与骨肉瘤部位显著相关,P值=0.004,HER-2强度评分与骨肉瘤部位存在差异(P=0.051)。在诊断时HER-2表达与转移的存在之间检测到统计学上显著的负相关(P=0.006),HER-2评分与转移的存在之间也发现显著相关,P值=0.046,因为超过一半的诊断时无转移病例(17/28例,60.7%)显示阳性强度评分。HER-2表达与患者年龄之间检测到统计学上显著的相关(P=0.044)。此外,HER-2表达与纤维组织的组织病理学检测显著相关,P值=0.033。HER-2表达的较高评分与显著更好的分化相关(P=0.038),因为检测到广泛的骨样区域与较高的HER-2评分相关。
仍需要进一步研究来阐明HER-2作为骨肉瘤患者治疗靶点的新希望所起的作用,主要是骨肉瘤,而软骨肉瘤根本不表达HER-2。