Hall Neil, Eldabe Sam
The James Cook University Hospital, Middlesbrough, UK.
Br J Pain. 2018 Nov;12(4):202-207. doi: 10.1177/2049463717747307. Epub 2017 Dec 15.
Phantom limb pain (PLP) is a complex condition resulting in pain in the missing limb affecting 60-80% amputees. Increasing number of patients are undergoing amputations. Approximately 1 per every 1000 people in the United Kingdom is an amputee. Incidence of PLP can be as high as 80% following amputation. PLP can be severe and difficult to treat. A range of pharmacological interventions exist yet little is known about them in respect to PLP. This article will address the effectiveness of both single pharmacological, therapy as well as drug combination therapy.
We reviewed all literature looking at the evidence for the efficacy of both single and combined pharmacological therapy in the management of phantom limb pain. Not all commonly prescribed analgesic agents have been studied in the use of PLP and in these cases, the evidence of their efficacy in neuropathic pain was reviewed.
It is difficult to draw definitive conclusions on the pharmacological management of PLP based on current available evidence. Most trials involved small cohorts and were not specific to the PLP. The trials which looked specifically at the PLP population gave conflicting results. Only the -methyl-d-aspartate (NMDA) receptor antagonist class demonstrated consistent positive results. Most notably ketamine did produce a reduction in pressure pain thresholds and pain windup associated with PLP, although the numbers in these studies remain small. This benefit was not demonstrated across all NMDA receptor antagonists. Combination therapy has demonstrated effectiveness in previous studies for neuropathic pain but this has never been tested specifically against a PLP cohort. Therefore, combination treatment of agents with proven efficacy in PLP such as opioid and gabapentin deserves a closer examination in a controlled study against a placebo as well as single drug therapy.
幻肢痛(PLP)是一种复杂的病症,导致缺失肢体出现疼痛,影响60%-80%的截肢者。接受截肢手术的患者数量在不断增加。在英国,每1000人中约有1人是截肢者。截肢后幻肢痛的发生率可高达80%。幻肢痛可能很严重且难以治疗。虽然存在一系列药物干预措施,但对于幻肢痛而言,人们对它们了解甚少。本文将探讨单一药物治疗、疗法以及联合药物治疗的有效性。
我们查阅了所有文献,以寻找单一和联合药物治疗在幻肢痛管理中疗效的证据。并非所有常用的镇痛药都已针对幻肢痛的使用进行研究,在这些情况下,我们查阅了它们在神经性疼痛中疗效的证据。
基于目前可得的证据,很难就幻肢痛的药物管理得出明确结论。大多数试验涉及的样本量较小,且并非专门针对幻肢痛。专门针对幻肢痛人群的试验给出了相互矛盾的结果。只有N-甲基-D-天冬氨酸(NMDA)受体拮抗剂类显示出一致的阳性结果。最值得注意的是,氯胺酮确实降低了与幻肢痛相关的压力痛阈值和疼痛累加,尽管这些研究中的样本量仍然较小。并非所有NMDA受体拮抗剂都显示出这种益处。联合治疗在先前的神经性疼痛研究中已证明有效,但从未专门针对幻肢痛人群进行测试。因此,在对照研究中,将在幻肢痛中已证明有效的药物(如阿片类药物和加巴喷丁)与安慰剂以及单一药物治疗进行联合治疗,值得更深入的研究。