Liang Dan, He Chao, Luo Xu, Liu Yang, Goodale Eben, Pagani-Núñez Emilio
State Key Laboratory of Biocontrol Department of Ecology/School of Life Sciences Sun Yat-sen University Guangzhou China.
Guangxi Key Laboratory of Forest Ecology and Conservation College of Forestry Guangxi University Nanning China.
Ecol Evol. 2018 Aug 29;8(18):9526-9535. doi: 10.1002/ece3.4460. eCollection 2018 Sep.
The pace-of-life hypothesis predicts no impact of urbanization on stress responses. Accordingly, several studies have been inconsistent in showing differences in breath rate (BR), a proxy of acute stress responses to handling in passerines, between rural and urban areas. However, this evidence is limited to a single bird species and a limited geographic region (SW Europe). No study addressed whether this pattern is also apparent in other species or regions, such as in tropical environments, or whether it is dependent on the level of diet specialization, given that diet restriction and change influence stress responses. Here, we tested whether there were differences in BR between habitats and diet groups using eight highly diverse passerine assemblages experiencing different levels of anthropogenic disturbance (i.e., natural, rural, and urban locations) in SW China. We predicted that insectivores and herbivores (frugivores, nectarivores, and seed-eating species) would show higher BR than omnivores. We also predicted no differences in BR among habitat types. BR was a moderately repeatable trait, which showed a negative relationship with body mass and a positive relationship with the time of the day. We also recorded a relatively strong phylogenetic bias in the expression of this trait. Confirming our predictions, our results showed no differences in BR among natural, rural, and urban locations. Similarly, within species, there were no differences in BR between rural and urban locations. However, we also found that herbivores showed higher BR than omnivores. Overall, our results provide support to the pace-of-life hypothesis, but suggest acute stress responses can be diet-mediated, which may help to explain the marked decline of specialized trophic guilds around the world in response to anthropogenic disturbance.
生活节奏假说预测城市化对压力反应没有影响。因此,几项研究在显示作为雀形目鸟类对处理的急性压力反应指标的呼吸频率(BR)在农村和城市地区之间的差异方面并不一致。然而,这一证据仅限于单一鸟类物种和有限的地理区域(欧洲西南部)。没有研究探讨这种模式在其他物种或地区(如热带环境)是否也明显,或者它是否取决于饮食专业化程度,因为饮食限制和变化会影响压力反应。在这里,我们利用中国西南部八个经历不同程度人为干扰(即自然、农村和城市地点)的高度多样化雀形目鸟类组合,测试了栖息地和饮食组之间的BR是否存在差异。我们预测食虫动物和食草动物(食果动物、食蜜动物和食种子物种)的BR会高于杂食动物。我们还预测栖息地类型之间的BR没有差异。BR是一个具有中等可重复性的性状,它与体重呈负相关,与一天中的时间呈正相关。我们还记录了该性状表达中相对较强的系统发育偏差。证实了我们的预测,我们的结果表明自然、农村和城市地点之间的BR没有差异。同样,在物种内部,农村和城市地点之间的BR也没有差异。然而,我们还发现食草动物的BR高于杂食动物。总体而言,我们的结果为生活节奏假说提供了支持,但表明急性压力反应可能由饮食介导,这可能有助于解释世界各地特化营养类群因人为干扰而显著减少的现象。