Palaco Ileana, Park Min Jae, Kim Suk Kyoung, Rho Jae Jeung
Global IT Technology Program (ITTP), Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology (KAIST), 291 Daehak-ro, Yuseong-gu, Daejeon, Republic of Korea.
Department of Business Administration, Seoul School of Integrated Sciences and Technologies (aSSIST), 46 Ewhayeodae 2-gil, Seodaemun-gu, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
Eval Program Plann. 2019 Feb;72:205-218. doi: 10.1016/j.evalprogplan.2018.10.015. Epub 2018 Oct 23.
Although public-private partnerships (PPP) and electronic government (e-government) have proven to be fruitful mechanisms for economic development and emerging economies seem to recognize their importance, consistent methods for analyzing the early planning stages of e-government portfolios are lacking. The present work utilized a comprehensive literature review to understand the evaluation criteria for PPP projects throughout the early-stage planning process. A qualitative meta-synthesis was employed to identify critical factors for PPP and e-government, with a particular focus on developing countries, PPP, and e-government criteria. Our research presents a framework named "PPP4e-Gov" (public-private partnerships for e-government). The framework compares risk and value factors of e-government PPP projects and adopts a weighted scoring model that estimates the risks that should be considered in a project and how much value a given e-government initiative may generate if the PPP option is chosen. As an illustration of how the framework may be used, the paper interviewed ten practitioners in Costa Rica who tried out PPP4e-Gov and showcased how to plan their e-government initiatives.
尽管公私伙伴关系(PPP)和电子政务已被证明是促进经济发展的有效机制,新兴经济体似乎也认识到了它们的重要性,但目前仍缺乏用于分析电子政务项目组合早期规划阶段的一致方法。本研究通过全面的文献综述,来了解公私伙伴关系项目在整个早期规划过程中的评估标准。采用定性元综合分析法来确定公私伙伴关系和电子政务的关键因素,特别关注发展中国家、公私伙伴关系和电子政务的标准。我们的研究提出了一个名为“PPP4e-Gov”(电子政务公私伙伴关系)的框架。该框架比较了电子政务公私伙伴关系项目的风险和价值因素,并采用加权评分模型来估计项目中应考虑的风险,以及如果选择公私伙伴关系选项,特定电子政务举措可能产生的价值。作为该框架使用方法的一个示例,本文采访了哥斯达黎加的十位从业者,他们试用了PPP4e-Gov,并展示了如何规划他们的电子政务举措。