Gil Joseph A, Weiss Barrett, Kleiner Justin, Akelman Edward, Weiss Arnold-Peter C
The Warren Alpert Medical School of Brown University, Providence, RI, USA.
Hand (N Y). 2020 May;15(3):315-321. doi: 10.1177/1558944718812155. Epub 2018 Nov 12.
The objective of this investigation is to examine the effect of postoperative therapy after routine carpal tunnel release. Our hypothesis was that supervised hand therapy does not improve outcomes after routine carpal tunnel release. : Patients with carpal tunnel syndrome were randomly assigned to one of 3 groups based on the last digit of their medical record numbers to one of 3 groups: standard 6-week postoperative rehabilitation (standard therapy), expedited one-session postoperative rehabilitation group (expedited therapy), and no postoperative rehabilitation group (no therapy). The primary outcome measures were Quick Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand (QuickDASH) and return to work. The outcome questionnaire was completed preoperatively, at the 2-week follow-up visit, and monthly to 6 months after surgery. All 3 treatment groups had similar mean QuickDASH scores preoperatively. At 1- to 6-month follow-up, all 3 groups had similar QuickDASH scores at each visit, and all showed a significant decline from baseline (preoperative) QuickDASH score. Overall, QuickDASH score decreased significantly from a preoperative visit mean of 42.7 to a final postoperative (visit 8) mean of 6.69. There was no significant difference in the mean QuickDASH score among all 3 groups at 6-month follow-up. There was no significance in the time of return to work among the 3 groups (standard therapy, 21.8 days; expedited therapy, 20.9 days; no therapy, 16.6 days). : This investigation adds evidence that supervised hand therapy does not improve the outcomes of routine carpal tunnel surgery as measured by QuickDASH and return to work.
本研究的目的是探讨常规腕管松解术后术后治疗的效果。我们的假设是,在常规腕管松解术后,有监督的手部治疗并不能改善治疗效果。患有腕管综合征的患者根据其病历号的最后一位数字被随机分为3组之一:标准的6周术后康复组(标准治疗)、加速的单次术后康复组(加速治疗)和无术后康复组(无治疗)。主要结局指标为手臂、肩部和手部快速残疾评定量表(QuickDASH)以及恢复工作情况。结局调查问卷在术前、术后2周随访时以及术后每月至6个月时完成。所有3个治疗组术前的平均QuickDASH评分相似。在1至6个月的随访中,所有3组在每次随访时的QuickDASH评分相似,且均显示较基线(术前)QuickDASH评分有显著下降。总体而言,QuickDASH评分从术前访视时的平均42.7显著降至术后最终(第8次访视)时的平均6.69。在6个月随访时,所有3组的平均QuickDASH评分无显著差异。3组之间恢复工作的时间无显著差异(标准治疗组为21.8天;加速治疗组为20.9天;无治疗组为16.6天)。本研究补充了证据,表明就QuickDASH和恢复工作情况而言,有监督的手部治疗并不能改善常规腕管手术的治疗效果。