Kotera Tomoaki, Seshadri Ananth
Department of Economics, University of Wisconsin-Madison, United States.
Rev Econ Dyn. 2017 Apr;25:187-207. doi: 10.1016/j.red.2017.02.005. Epub 2017 Feb 16.
In the United States, there is considerable variation in intergenerational mobility across states. We argue that the distribution of public school spending across school districts under public school finance systems affects intergenerational mobility within the United States. We build a dynamic model in which school districts vote over public school spending per pupil taking the finance system as given. We embed this model with median voting at the district level within a fairly standard model of human capital accumulation. Our model can replicate the relationship between the distribution of public school spending and intergenerational mobility observed in data. Furthermore, three counterfactual simulations suggest that i) the correlation between parental human capital and a child's learning ability plays a significant role in explaining the cross-state variation in intergenerational mobility, ii) a more equal distribution of public school spending under a foundation program by relaxing a borrowing constraint improves intergenerational mobility, especially when a child's learning ability is not highly dependent on parental human capital, and iii) switching to a full state funding program improves intergenerational mobility, but not enormously. This is because full state funding limits public school spending, which hinders intergenerational mobility.
在美国,各州之间的代际流动性存在很大差异。我们认为,公立学校财政体系下学区之间公立学校支出的分布会影响美国国内的代际流动性。我们构建了一个动态模型,在该模型中,学区在将财政体系视为既定的情况下,对每个学生的公立学校支出进行投票。我们将这个在学区层面进行中位数投票的模型嵌入到一个相当标准的人力资本积累模型中。我们的模型能够复制数据中观察到的公立学校支出分布与代际流动性之间的关系。此外,三个反事实模拟表明:i)父母人力资本与孩子学习能力之间的相关性在解释代际流动性的州际差异方面发挥着重要作用;ii)通过放宽借款限制,在基础项目下实现更平等的公立学校支出分配能够改善代际流动性,尤其是当孩子的学习能力不太依赖于父母人力资本时;iii)转向完全由州政府资助的项目能够改善代际流动性,但改善幅度不大。这是因为完全由州政府资助会限制公立学校支出,从而阻碍代际流动性。