Rehabilitation Sciences Institute, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
Department of Occupational Science and Occupational Therapy, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
Disabil Rehabil. 2020 Feb;42(4):574-585. doi: 10.1080/09638288.2018.1503734. Epub 2018 Nov 18.
There is a growing movement in pediatric rehabilitation to understand how approaches addressing aspects beyond body function contribute to enhanced psychosocial well-being. Among such approaches is the use of creative arts. A scoping review was undertaken to synthesize the current literature on performance and visual arts-based programs and outcomes for children with disabilities. Data sources included CINAHL, MEDLINE, and PsycINFO. Eligible articles described programs involving performing or visual art activities in community and ambulatory care settings, delivered to children between 6 and 18 years with physical or developmental disabilities, and reported on at least one psychosocial outcome. Domains of interest included emotional, social, behavioral, physical, cognitive, and/or communicative functioning, which are known to impact well-being and participation. No limits were applied to study design. Twelve articles using primarily case study and quasi-experimental designs were identified, encompassing an 11-year period. Most programs focused on theater as the central modality. A majority of papers addressed changes in physical, cognitive, and communicative function ( = 8), followed by social function ( = 6), emotional function ( = 5), and finally, behavioral function ( = 3). Across individual papers, diverse study designs, measures, and outcomes were examined with positive qualitative and/or quantitative findings noted across all domains. Within an emerging evidence base, arts-based programs show potential to positively impact psychosocial well-being and warrant further investigation with broader populations of children with physical and developmental disabilities. A greater emphasis on programmatic approaches and enhanced methodological rigor to establishing benefits is needed to advance understanding.Implications for rehabilitationPediatric therapists may wish to consider recommending arts-based programs for children with ASD, TBI, and other developmental disabilities given their potential in achieving psychosocial outcomesArts-based programs in rehabilitation provide creative ideas (e.g., drawing, painting) and techniques (e.g., modeling, role-play), which may be incorporated into individualized or group-based therapy to promote psychosocial well-beingProgram evaluators and researchers are encouraged to adopt a programmatic approach to further explore how art activities facilitate psychosocial outcomes.
在儿科康复领域,人们越来越认识到,除了身体功能之外,还需要关注其他方面,以促进儿童的心理社会幸福感。在这些方法中,创造性艺术的应用受到了关注。本研究旨在对基于表演和视觉艺术的残疾儿童项目及结果的现有文献进行综合分析。数据来源包括 CINAHL、MEDLINE 和 PsycINFO。纳入的文献描述了在社区和门诊环境中开展的涉及表演或视觉艺术活动的项目,其服务对象为 6 至 18 岁的身体或发育残疾儿童,且至少报告了一项心理社会结果。感兴趣的领域包括影响幸福感和参与度的情绪、社会、行为、身体、认知和/或交流功能。本研究未对研究设计进行限制。共确定了 12 篇主要采用案例研究和准实验设计的文章,涵盖了 11 年的时间。大多数项目都以戏剧为核心模式。大多数论文都涉及身体、认知和交流功能的变化( = 8),其次是社会功能( = 6)、情绪功能( = 5)和行为功能( = 3)。在个别论文中,还考察了不同的研究设计、措施和结果,所有领域都记录了积极的定性和/或定量发现。在不断发展的证据基础上,艺术项目显示出对心理社会幸福感产生积极影响的潜力,需要对更多身体和发育残疾儿童进行研究,以进一步证实其效果。
对康复的启示
鉴于艺术项目在实现心理社会结果方面的潜力,儿科治疗师可能希望考虑为自闭症谱系障碍、创伤性脑损伤和其他发育障碍儿童推荐此类项目。
康复中的艺术项目提供了创造性的想法(如绘画、绘画)和技术(如建模、角色扮演),这些想法可被纳入个体化或小组治疗中,以促进心理社会幸福感。
鼓励计划评估员和研究人员采用项目方法,进一步探讨艺术活动如何促进心理社会结果。