Department of Sociology, Kent State University, Kent, OH, 44242, United States.
Department of Sociology, Kent State University, United States.
Soc Sci Med. 2019 Jan;220:212-218. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2018.10.028. Epub 2018 Nov 1.
In 1965, Glaser and Strauss (1965) offered the concept of "awareness contexts" to explain what patients in hospitals do or don't know about their death trajectories. Awareness ranges from closed (where patients are completely unaware and family and providers protect "the secret") to open (where all parties communicate openly and honestly). While closed awareness was the norm in 1960s, open awareness is now considered standard practice in US, a reflection of mounting evidence that patients, families, and providers benefit from clear and honest communication at end of life (Seale et al., 1997; Wright et al., 2008). Despite the known benefits of open awareness, many terminal patients remain unaware or confused about their prognoses (Chen et al., 2017). This paper asks why, in an era of open awareness, are patients and families uncertain about dying? To answer this question, we focus on an aspect of Glaser and Strauss's theory that remains relatively understudied by researchers, namely the role of institutional and organizational realities in shaping awareness contexts. Based on interviews with 43 family members of deceased patients who died at General Hospital in the Midwestern US, we argue that two related conditions in hospitals-the increased specialization of medical professionals and the fragmentation of patient care-serve as important context for the death awareness of patients and families.
1965 年,格拉泽(Glaser)和施特劳斯(Strauss)(1965)提出了“意识背景”的概念,用以解释医院中的患者对其死亡轨迹的了解或不了解情况。意识范围从封闭(患者完全不知情,家属和医护人员保护“秘密”)到开放(所有各方公开坦诚地交流)。虽然在 20 世纪 60 年代,封闭意识是常态,但现在在美国,开放意识被认为是标准做法,这反映了越来越多的证据表明,在生命末期,患者、家属和医护人员从清晰坦诚的沟通中受益(Seale 等人,1997;Wright 等人,2008)。尽管开放意识有其已知的益处,但许多晚期患者仍然对其预后感到茫然或困惑(Chen 等人,2017)。本文探讨了在开放意识的时代,为什么患者和家属对死亡感到不确定?为了回答这个问题,我们专注于格拉泽和施特劳斯理论中一个相对较少被研究人员研究的方面,即机构和组织现实在塑造意识背景方面的作用。基于对在美国中西部综合医院去世的 43 名患者家属的访谈,我们认为医院中两个相关的情况——医疗专业人员的日益专业化和患者护理的碎片化——是患者和家属死亡意识的重要背景。