Schlickum L, Quadlbauer S, Pezzei Ch, Stöphasius E, Hausner T, Leixnering M
AUVA Trauma Hospital Lorenz Böhler-European Hand Trauma Center, Donaueschingenstraße 13, 1200, Vienna, Austria.
Ludwig Boltzmann Institute for Experimental und Clinical Traumatology, AUVA Research Center, Donaueschingenstraße 13, 1200, Vienna, Austria.
Arch Orthop Trauma Surg. 2019 Feb;139(2):269-279. doi: 10.1007/s00402-018-3081-z. Epub 2018 Dec 1.
The standard therapy of intra-articular and extra-articular distal radius fractures consists of open reduction and stabilization using palmar osteosynthesis with an angularly stable plate. The integrity of the flexor pollicis longus tendon (FPLT) may be mechanically affected by the plate, with rupture rates between 1 and 12% reported in the literature, occurring during a postoperative time period from 4 to 120 months. The aim of this study was to investigate the position of the tendon in relation to the distal edge of the plate using high-resolution ultrasonic imaging.
Nineteen patients undergoing osteosynthesis for distal radius fracture in 2015 with the Medartis APTUS FPL plate were included in this study. Of these, seven dropped out for various reasons. Therefore, twelve patients with a median age of 52 years (range 24-82 years) were included in the final analysis. High-frequency ultrasound was performed within a median of 28 (range 10-52) weeks by an experienced radiology specialist to locate the FPLT position in two separate wrist positions: (1) wrist held in 0° position and fingers extended and (2) wrist held in 45° of dorsal extension and actively flexed fingers II to V (functional position). For analysis, we used the axial ultrasound videos. Postoperative X-rays and CT scans were included for the analysis, especially the soft-tissue CT scan window for the exact localization of the FPLT. Dynamic ultrasound scanning was used to localize the FPLT in relation to the plate in 0° and functional position of the hand. Using CT scanning, the position of the plate relative to the bone was determined. In this way, we were able to correlate the functional FPLT position with the osseous structures of the distal radius.
In all cases, the FPLT was positioned closer to the volar distal edge of the FPL plate in functional position than in 0° position. In four cases, the FPLT did not touch the plate at all and was shown to shift diagonally from radio-volar in ulno-dorsal direction during wrist movement from 0° to functional position, similarly to the sliding of the tendon in the assumed physiological motion sequence. In these cases, in the functional position the center of the FPLT was positioned slightly ulnarly of the center of the distal radius (i.e., less than 50% of the distal radius width measured from the radial border of DRUJ), and positioned more ulnarly than in all other cases (i.e., in which the FPLT came into contact with the plate). In the remaining two-thirds of the cases (eight patients), the FPLT touched the plate during wrist movement from 0° to functional position, shifted in dorsal direction and slid into the plate indentation, irrespective of whether the tendon entered the indentation from the radial or the ulnar side, and independent of the ulnoradial position of the plate. No signs of tendinopathy of the FPLT were found in any of the cases.
The results show that the indentation of the Medartis APTUS FPL plate reduces the tendon-plate contact and ideally even prevents it entirely. In particular, ulnar positioning of the plate lowers the risk of tendon-plate contact. If the FPLT touches the plate, the tendon pulls into the plate indentation, thus lowering the contact. Consequently, the Soong criteria are not applicable when a FPL plate is used.
桡骨远端关节内和关节外骨折的标准治疗方法是采用掌侧角度稳定钢板进行切开复位和内固定。拇长屈肌腱(FPLT)的完整性可能会受到钢板的机械影响,文献报道的断裂率在1%至12%之间,发生在术后4至120个月的时间段内。本研究的目的是使用高分辨率超声成像研究肌腱相对于钢板远端边缘的位置。
本研究纳入了2015年接受桡骨远端骨折内固定治疗且使用Medartis APTUS FPL钢板的19例患者。其中,7例因各种原因退出。因此,最终分析纳入了12例患者,中位年龄为52岁(范围24 - 82岁)。由经验丰富的放射科专家在中位时间28周(范围10 - 52周)内进行高频超声检查,以确定FPLT在两个不同腕关节位置的位置:(1)腕关节保持在0°位置且手指伸展;(2)腕关节保持在背伸45°且手指II至V主动屈曲(功能位)。为进行分析,我们使用了轴向超声视频。纳入术后X线和CT扫描进行分析,特别是软组织CT扫描窗口以精确确定FPLT的位置。使用动态超声扫描在手部的0°和功能位确定FPLT相对于钢板的位置。通过CT扫描,确定钢板相对于骨骼的位置。通过这种方式,我们能够将功能性FPLT位置与桡骨远端的骨性结构相关联。
在所有病例中,FPLT在功能位比在0°位更靠近FPL钢板的掌侧远端边缘。在4例病例中,FPLT根本未接触钢板,并且在腕关节从0°位移动到功能位时显示从桡掌侧斜向尺背侧移位,类似于肌腱在假定的生理运动序列中的滑动。在这些病例中,在功能位FPLT的中心位于桡骨远端中心的稍尺侧(即从尺桡远侧关节桡侧边缘测量的桡骨远端宽度的不到50%),并且比所有其他病例(即FPLT与钢板接触的病例)更偏向尺侧。在其余三分之二的病例(8例患者)中,FPLT在腕关节从0°位移动到功能位时接触钢板,向背侧移位并滑入钢板凹槽,无论肌腱是从桡侧还是尺侧进入凹槽,且与钢板的尺桡位置无关。在任何病例中均未发现FPLT的肌腱病迹象。
结果表明,Medartis APTUS FPL钢板的凹槽减少了肌腱与钢板的接触,理想情况下甚至可完全防止这种接触。特别是钢板的尺侧定位降低了肌腱与钢板接触的风险。如果FPLT接触钢板,肌腱会拉入钢板凹槽,从而减少接触。因此,当使用FPL钢板时,宋氏标准不适用。