Reyes B Humberto
Academia Chilena de Medicina, Chile.
Rev Med Chil. 2018 Aug;146(8):913-920. doi: 10.4067/s0034-98872018000800913.
Medical journals are fundamental elements in medical education, in professional life, in research and in academic careers. They communicate new scientific and clinical findings, legitimate and give credibility to biomedical and clinical investigation, are guarantors of the authors' intellectual property, are a useful forum for the discussion of relevant topics, distribute selected information to readers and are archives of their publications. Out of the numerous medical journals appeared before and during the XIXth Century, only 24 of them remain active until today and Revista Médica de Chile appears as number 20 in the list. Nowadays thousands of medical journals are published worldwide but only a small fraction are qualified as "mainstream journals", because they strictly apply an independent editorial process with clear criteria in manuscript selection based in external peer review, format requisites according to ICMJE Recommendations, are included in major databases, publish a high proportion of research articles, and other reasons. English language predominates in mainstream journals and abstracts in English become available in some databases. Electronic publications and open access are important tools to disseminate new information but the appearance of "predatory journals" is a threatening menace to the integrity of medical publications. Authors should identify and reject them. Some reflections may help those who intend to create new medical journals.
医学期刊是医学教育、职业生涯、研究以及学术生涯中的基本要素。它们传播新的科学和临床发现,使生物医学和临床研究具有合法性和可信度,是作者知识产权的保障者,是讨论相关话题的有用论坛,向读者传播精选信息,并保存其出版物档案。在19世纪之前及期间出现的众多医学期刊中,至今仍活跃的只有24种,而《智利医学杂志》在这份名单中位列第20。如今,全球出版了数千种医学期刊,但只有一小部分被视为“主流期刊”,因为它们严格采用独立的编辑流程,在稿件选择上有明确标准,基于外部同行评审,根据国际医学期刊编辑委员会(ICMJE)的建议有格式要求,被收录在主要数据库中,发表的研究文章比例较高,以及其他原因。主流期刊中英语占主导地位,一些数据库提供英文摘要。电子出版物和开放获取是传播新信息的重要工具,但“掠夺性期刊”的出现对医学出版物的完整性构成了威胁。作者应识别并拒绝它们。一些思考可能有助于那些打算创办新医学期刊的人。