Neshati Hashem, Sheybani Fereshte, Naderi HamidReza, Sarvghad MohamadReza, Soltani Ahmad Khalifeh, Efterkharpoor Elaheh, Nooghabi Mehdi Jabbari
Faculty of Medicine, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran.
Department of Infectious Diseases and Tropical Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran.
J Environ Public Health. 2018 Nov 13;2018:1975931. doi: 10.1155/2018/1975931. eCollection 2018.
Although there is still much to learn about the types of errors committed in health care and why they occur, enough is known today to recognize that a serious concern exists for patients. Tuberculosis (TB) is an infectious disease that is frequently subject to diagnostic errors. Missed or delayed diagnosis of TB can affect patients and community adversely. Our aim in the present study was at evaluating the type of diagnostic errors in TB patients from symptom onset to diagnosis. This was a multicenter cross-sectional study conducted in three university hospitals in Mashhad, Iran. We showed a long delay in diagnosing TB that is mostly related to the time from first medical visit to diagnosis. Errors in the diagnostic process were identified in 97.5% of patients. The most common type of error in diagnosing TB was failure in hypothesis generation (72%), followed by history taking and physical examination. In conclusion, it seems likely that efforts to improve public awareness of and health literacy for TB, to coordinate the referral and follow-up systems of patients, and to improve physicians' skills in history taking and physical examination and clinical reasoning will result in reduced delay in diagnosis of TB and, perhaps, improved patient safety and community health.
尽管对于医疗保健中所犯错误的类型以及为何会出现这些错误仍有许多需要了解的地方,但如今已知的情况足以认识到患者面临着严重的问题。结核病(TB)是一种经常出现诊断错误的传染病。结核病的漏诊或诊断延迟会对患者和社区产生不利影响。我们在本研究中的目的是评估结核病患者从症状出现到诊断期间的诊断错误类型。这是一项在伊朗马什哈德的三家大学医院进行的多中心横断面研究。我们发现结核病诊断存在长时间延迟,这主要与从首次就诊到诊断的时间有关。97.5%的患者在诊断过程中存在错误。结核病诊断中最常见的错误类型是未能提出假设(72%),其次是病史采集和体格检查。总之,提高公众对结核病的认识和健康素养、协调患者的转诊和随访系统以及提高医生的病史采集、体格检查和临床推理技能,似乎有可能减少结核病的诊断延迟,也许还能提高患者安全性和社区健康水平。