Haddad Mahboubeh, Sheybani Fereshte, Naderi HamidReza, Sasan Mohammad Saeed, Najaf Najafi Mona, Sedighi Malihe, Seddigh Atena
Department of Infectious Diseases and Tropical Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran.
Department of Pediatrics, Faculty of Medicine, Mashhad University of Medical Sciences, Mashhad, Iran.
Front Med (Lausanne). 2021 Nov 17;8:779454. doi: 10.3389/fmed.2021.779454. eCollection 2021.
Infectious diseases are commonly missed or misdiagnosed. Errors in diagnosing infectious diseases not only affect the patient but also the community health. To describe our investigation on the most common errors in diagnosing infectious diseases and their causes according to the physicians' reports. Between August 2018 and February 2019, specialist physicians and residents across Mashhad, Iran were invited to participate in a survey to report errors they had made or witnessed regarding the diagnosis of infectious diseases. Overall, 465 cases were reported by 315 participants. The most common infectious diseases affected by diagnostic errors were upper respiratory tract infections (URTIs) ( = 69, 14.8%), tuberculosis (TB) ( = 66, 14.1%), pleuro-pulmonary infections ( = 54, 11.6%), central nervous system (CNS) infections ( = 51, 10.9%), and urinary tract infections ( = 45, 9.6%). Errors occurred most frequently in generating a diagnostic hypothesis ( = 259, 55/7%), followed by history taking ( = 200, 43%), and physical examination ( = 191, 41/1%). Errors related to the diagnosis of TB (odds ratio [OR]: 2.4, 95% confidence interval [CI]:0.9-5.7; value: 0.047) and intra-abdominal infections (OR: 7.2, 95% CI: 0.9-53.8; value: 0.02) were associated with more-serious outcomes. A substantial proportion of errors in diagnosing infectious diseases moderately or seriously affect patients' outcomes. URTIs, TB, and pleuropulmonary infections were the most frequently reported infectious diseases involved in diagnostic error while errors related to the diagnosis of TB and intraabdominal infections were more frequently associated with poor outcomes. Therefore, contagious and potentially life-threatening infectious diseases should always be considered in the differential diagnosis of patients who present with compatible clinical syndromes.
传染病常常被漏诊或误诊。传染病诊断错误不仅影响患者,还会影响社区健康。根据医生的报告,描述我们对传染病诊断中最常见错误及其原因的调查。2018年8月至2019年2月,伊朗马什哈德的专科医生和住院医师受邀参与一项调查,报告他们在传染病诊断方面所犯或目睹的错误。总体而言,315名参与者报告了465例病例。受诊断错误影响最常见的传染病是上呼吸道感染(URTIs)(n = 69,14.8%)、结核病(TB)(n = 66,14.1%)、胸膜肺部感染(n = 54,11.6%)、中枢神经系统(CNS)感染(n = 51,10.9%)和尿路感染(n = 45,9.6%)。错误最常发生在提出诊断假设(n = 259,55.7%),其次是病史采集(n = 200,43%)和体格检查(n = 191,41.1%)。与结核病诊断相关的错误(比值比[OR]:2.4,95%置信区间[CI]:0.9 - 5.7;P值:0.047)和腹腔内感染(OR:7.2,95%CI:0.9 - 53.8;P值:0.02)与更严重的后果相关。传染病诊断中的很大一部分错误对患者的预后有中度或严重影响。URTIs、结核病和胸膜肺部感染是诊断错误中最常报告的传染病,而与结核病和腹腔内感染诊断相关的错误更常与不良预后相关。因此,对于出现符合临床综合征的患者进行鉴别诊断时,应始终考虑传染性和潜在危及生命的传染病。