Water Management Department, Civil Engineering and Geosciences, TU Delft, Stevinweg 1, 2628 CN, Delft, the Netherlands; Integral Design and Management, Civil Engineering and Geosciences, TU Delft, Stevinweg 1, 2628 CN, Delft, the Netherlands.
Laboratory of Reclamation Works and Water Resources Management, School of Rural and Surveying Engineering, National Technical University of Athens, 9, Iroon Polytechneiou Str, 15780, Zografou, Athens, Greece.
Water Res. 2019 Mar 1;150:368-379. doi: 10.1016/j.watres.2018.11.079. Epub 2018 Dec 5.
This paper aims to stimulate discussion based on the experiences derived from the QUICS project (Quantifying Uncertainty in Integrated Catchment Studies). First it briefly discusses the current state of knowledge on uncertainties in sub-models of integrated catchment models and the existing frameworks for analysing uncertainty. Furthermore, it compares the relative approaches of both building and calibrating fully integrated models or linking separate sub-models. It also discusses the implications of model linkage on overall uncertainty and how to define an acceptable level of model complexity. This discussion includes, whether we should shift our attention from uncertainties due to linkage, when using linked models, to uncertainties in model structure by necessary simplification or by using more parameters. This discussion attempts to address the question as to whether there is an increase in uncertainty by linking these models or if a compensation effect could take place and that overall uncertainty in key water quality parameters actually decreases. Finally, challenges in the application of uncertainty analysis in integrated catchment water quality modelling, as encountered in this project, are discussed and recommendations for future research areas are highlighted.
本文旨在基于 QUICS 项目(综合流域研究中的不确定性量化)所获得的经验,引发讨论。首先,简要讨论了综合流域模型子模型不确定性的现有知识状况以及分析不确定性的现有框架。此外,还比较了构建和校准完全集成模型或链接单独子模型的相对方法。还讨论了模型链接对整体不确定性的影响,以及如何定义可接受的模型复杂性水平。讨论包括,当使用链接模型时,我们是否应该将注意力从由于链接引起的不确定性转移到通过必要的简化或使用更多参数来转移到模型结构中的不确定性。本讨论试图回答以下问题:通过链接这些模型是否会增加不确定性,或者是否会产生补偿效应,以及关键水质参数的整体不确定性实际上是否会降低。最后,讨论了在综合流域水质建模中应用不确定性分析所遇到的挑战,并强调了未来研究领域的建议。