Department of Anaesthesia, The Rotunda Hospital, Parnell Square, Dublin, Ireland.
University of Cape Town, Cape Town, South Africa.
Ir J Med Sci. 2019 Aug;188(3):979-986. doi: 10.1007/s11845-018-1944-5. Epub 2018 Dec 14.
Rigid bronchoscopy may be used to relieve acute airway obstruction following induction of anaesthesia and is a recommended option for management of the difficult airway. The ability of anaesthetists to perform rigid bronchoscopy has not been reported. We sought to explore the acquisition of procedural skill in rigid bronchoscopy by anaesthesiologists in a manikin.
In a prospective interventional study, participants were asked to perform 40 rigid bronchoscopies in a TruCorp AirSim Advance airway manikin, configured to a randomised sequence of easy or difficult laryngoscopic grades to which the participants were blinded. The primary outcome was stabilisation (the attempt after which no further reduction in procedural time occurred). Dental injury and oesophageal intubation were also recorded. Forty anaesthesiologists and 40 unskilled controls (without laryngoscopic skills) participated.
In the easy model, stabilisation occurred at attempt 8 in the anaesthesiology group and 10 in the unskilled controls. In the difficult model, stabilisation occurred at attempt 10 in both groups. Dental injury was less common in the anaesthesiology group. The proportion of participants achieving procedural competency did not differ between groups in either the easy (35/40 vs. 30/40) or difficult model (32/40 vs. 25/40).
This study shows that the technical skill of rigid bronchoscopy can be acquired within 10 repetitions in a manikin model. As procedural competence and complication frequency vary with the laryngoscopic grade of the model, both easy and difficult configurations should be used for training. Advanced laryngoscopic skills are not required prior to training in this technique.
在全身麻醉诱导后发生急性气道阻塞时,可使用硬性支气管镜来缓解气道阻塞,这是处理困难气道的推荐方法。麻醉师进行硬性支气管镜检查的能力尚未得到报道。我们试图在模拟人体模型中探索麻醉师在硬性支气管镜检查方面的程序技能获取情况。
在一项前瞻性干预研究中,要求参与者在 TruCorp AirSim Advance 气道模拟人体模型中进行 40 次硬性支气管镜检查,该模型按照参与者无法看到的随机困难或容易的喉镜分级序列进行配置。主要结果是稳定(即尝试后程序时间不再减少的尝试)。还记录了牙齿损伤和食管插管。共有 40 名麻醉师和 40 名非熟练对照组(无喉镜技能)参加。
在容易模型中,麻醉组在尝试 8 次时达到稳定,而非熟练对照组在尝试 10 次时达到稳定。在困难模型中,两组均在尝试 10 次时达到稳定。在麻醉组中,牙齿损伤的发生率较低。在容易模型(35/40 与 30/40)或困难模型(32/40 与 25/40)中,两组达到程序能力的参与者比例均无差异。
本研究表明,在模拟人体模型中,硬性支气管镜检查的技术技能可以在 10 次重复内获得。由于程序能力和并发症频率随模型的喉镜分级而变化,因此应同时使用容易和困难的配置进行培训。在进行该技术培训之前,不需要高级的喉镜技能。