Folz Rachel, Ali Moazzam
Department of Reproductive Health and Research, World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland.
East Mediterr Health J. 2018 Dec 9;24(9):940-950. doi: 10.26719/2018.24.9.940.
Community health workers (CHWs) help reduce healthcare disparities and improve access to and quality of care in many countries.
To provide an overview to compare and contrast characteristics of CHW programmes in Egypt, Pakistan and Afghanistan and describe the strengths, weaknesses and challenges of the programmes.
Scientific databases and grey literature were searched including PubMed, Medline, Cochrane Review Library, WHO databases, and grey literature websites including those of national health ministries. We shortlisted 23 articles to be included in this study.
The three programmes reviewed vary in their organization, structure, enrolment and payment structure for CHWs. Key challenges identified in the review include: commodity security that compromises quality of services; inadequate and irregular training; unpredictable or inadequate remuneration structure; and lack of standardization among organizations and government ministries. Strengths identified are that the programmes are accepted and integrated into many communities; and have the support of health ministries, which enhances sustainability and regulates standardized training and supervision. These also increase participation and empowerment of women, evident in the fact that CHWs have organized among themselves to demand better treatment and more respect for the work that they do.
Our findings should alert policy-makers to the need to review CHWs' scope of practice, update education curricula, and prioritize in-service training modules and improved working conditions. The effectiveness and impact of CHW programmes has been shown countless times, demonstrating that task sharing in healthcare is a successful strategy with which to approach global health goals.
社区卫生工作者(CHW)有助于减少许多国家的医疗保健差距,并改善医疗服务的可及性和质量。
概述并比较埃及、巴基斯坦和阿富汗的社区卫生工作者项目的特点,描述这些项目的优势、劣势和挑战。
检索了科学数据库和灰色文献,包括PubMed、Medline、Cochrane系统评价图书馆、世界卫生组织数据库,以及包括各国卫生部网站在内的灰色文献网站。我们筛选出23篇文章纳入本研究。
所审查的三个项目在社区卫生工作者的组织、结构、招募和薪酬结构方面各不相同。审查中确定的主要挑战包括:影响服务质量的商品安全问题;培训不足且不规律;薪酬结构不可预测或不足;以及各组织和政府部门之间缺乏标准化。确定的优势在于这些项目被许多社区接受并融入其中;并得到了卫生部的支持,这增强了可持续性,并规范了标准化培训和监督。这些项目还提高了妇女的参与度和赋权,社区卫生工作者自行组织起来要求更好的待遇和对其工作更多尊重这一事实就证明了这一点。
我们的研究结果应提醒政策制定者,有必要审查社区卫生工作者的执业范围,更新教育课程,优先安排在职培训模块并改善工作条件。社区卫生工作者项目的有效性和影响已被无数次证明,表明医疗保健中的任务分担是实现全球卫生目标的一项成功战略。