Davies Justine I, Vreede Eric, Onajin-Obembe Bisola, Morriss Wayne W
Medical Research Council/Wits University Rural Public Health and Health Transitions Research Unit, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of the Witwatersrand School of Public Health, Johannesburg, South Africa.
Institute for Allied Health Research, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK.
BMJ Glob Health. 2018 Dec 1;3(6):e001005. doi: 10.1136/bmjgh-2018-001005. eCollection 2018.
The number of specialist anaesthetists in most low-income and middle-income countries is below what is needed to provide a safe quality anaesthesia service. There are no estimates of the optimal number; therefore, we estimated the minimum density of specialist anaesthetists to achieve a reasonable standard of healthcare as indicated by the maternal mortality ratio (MMR).
Utilising existing country-level data of the number of physician anaesthesia providers (PAPs), MMR and Human Development Index (HDI), we developed best-fit curves to describe the relationship between MMR and PAPs, controlling for HDI. The aim was to use this relationship to estimate the number of PAPs associated with achieving the median MMR.
We estimated that, in order to achieve a reasonable standard of healthcare, as indicated by the global median MMR, countries should aim to have at least four PAPs per 100 000 population. Existing data show that currently 80 countries have fewer than this number.
Four PAPs per 100 000 population is a modest target, but there is a need to increase training of doctors in many countries in order to train more specialist anaesthetists. It is important that this target is considered during the development of national workforce plans, even if a stepwise approach to workforce planning is chosen.
大多数低收入和中等收入国家的专科麻醉医生数量低于提供安全优质麻醉服务所需的数量。目前尚无关于最佳数量的估计;因此,我们根据孕产妇死亡率(MMR)来估计专科麻醉医生的最低密度,以实现合理的医疗保健标准。
利用现有的国家层面关于麻醉医生提供者(PAPs)数量、MMR和人类发展指数(HDI)的数据,我们绘制了最佳拟合曲线,以描述MMR与PAPs之间的关系,并控制HDI的影响。目的是利用这种关系来估计与实现中位数MMR相关的PAPs数量。
我们估计,为了实现全球中位数MMR所表明的合理医疗保健标准,各国每10万人口应至少有4名PAPs。现有数据显示,目前有80个国家的这一数量低于该标准。
每10万人口中有4名PAPs是一个适度的目标,但许多国家需要加强对医生的培训,以培养更多的专科麻醉医生。即使选择逐步推进劳动力规划方法,在制定国家劳动力计划时考虑这一目标也很重要。