Safavi Amir H, Shi Qian, Ding Maylynn, Kotait Maryam, Profetto Jason, Mohialdin Vian, Shali Ari
Medical Education and Simulation, McMaster University, Hamilton, CAN.
Family Medicine, McMaster University, Hamilton, CAN.
Cureus. 2018 Oct 23;10(10):e3484. doi: 10.7759/cureus.3484.
Introduction Many undergraduate medical education (UME) programs have begun adopting point-of-care ultrasound (PoCUS) curricula, reflecting the increasing ubiquity of this technique across medical specialties. The structures of international PoCUS curricula have been extensively studied. However, the efficacy of these curricula to increase knowledge and confidence in PoCUS is less well-studied. We investigated whether a structured, small-group PoCUS teaching session consisting of pre-defined learning objectives, an introductory presentation, and a mandatory hands-on scanning component would increase pre-clerk knowledge of and confidence in PoCUS theory, use, and interpretation. Methods A pre-post study was designed to assess changes in pre-clerk knowledge and confidence in PoCUS theory, use, and interpretation. Pre-clerks were recruited from the Hamilton campus of the Michael G. DeGroote School of Medicine at McMaster University. Pre-clerks were organized into four groups, with an average group size of seven learners. Two preceptors each taught two groups. Sessions included an introductory PowerPoint presentation and one-on-one preceptor-guided practice in identifying abdominal and genitourinary structures using PoCUS. Student responses on pre- and post-intervention surveys were analyzed to identify changes in knowledge and confidence. Student satisfaction with the teaching session was assessed from self-reported levels of agreement with satisfaction statements. The strengths and areas of improvement for the teaching sessions were identified from open-ended survey responses. Results Data from 27 students indicated a significant improvement in knowledge test scores (p < .05), with no significant differences between groups (F(3,23) = 0.64, p = n.s.) or between students with different preceptors (p = n.s.). Students' confidence in PoCUS use and interpretation improved significantly (p < .05 for both), with no significant differences between groups (F(3,23) = 0.70, p = n.s. and F(3,23) = 0.32, p = n.s., respectively) or between students with different preceptors (p = n.s. for both). Improvements in knowledge of and confidence in PoCUS use were significantly correlated (r = .44, p < .05). All of the students agreed that they liked the instruction, content, and structure of the teaching session. The most frequently cited strengths of the teaching sessions were the mandatory individual practice time per student, individualized instruction from and interactions with preceptors, and the small group structure of the sessions. Conclusion This study provides novel evidence that a structured, small-group teaching session featuring a didactic presentation, defined learning objectives, and mandatory hands-on learning can effectively teach introductory PoCUS knowledge and skills to pre-clerks and increase student confidence. Future studies will investigate the retention and application of PoCUS knowledge and skill throughout clerkship and early residency training to determine if this teaching model can facilitate longitudinal PoCUS learning and competency as well as improved diagnostic capabilities as students advance through undergraduate medical training.
引言 许多本科医学教育(UME)项目已开始采用床旁超声(PoCUS)课程,这反映出该技术在各个医学专业中越来越普遍。国际PoCUS课程的结构已得到广泛研究。然而,这些课程在增加PoCUS知识和信心方面的效果研究较少。我们调查了一个结构化的小组PoCUS教学课程,该课程包括预先定义的学习目标、一个介绍性演示以及一个强制性的实践扫描环节,是否会增加见习前学生在PoCUS理论、使用和解读方面的知识和信心。
方法 设计了一项前后对照研究,以评估见习前学生在PoCUS理论、使用和解读方面的知识和信心的变化。见习前学生从麦克马斯特大学迈克尔·G·德格罗特医学院汉密尔顿校区招募。见习前学生被分成四组,每组平均有七名学习者。两名带教老师各教两组。课程包括一个介绍性的PowerPoint演示以及在带教老师一对一指导下使用PoCUS识别腹部和泌尿生殖系统结构的实践。分析学生在干预前后调查中的回答,以确定知识和信心的变化。通过学生对满意度陈述自我报告的同意程度来评估学生对教学课程的满意度。从开放式调查回答中确定教学课程的优点和改进领域。
结果 27名学生的数据表明,知识测试成绩有显著提高(p < 0.05),组间(F(3,23) = 0.64,p = 无显著差异)或不同带教老师的学生之间(p = 无显著差异)均无显著差异。学生在PoCUS使用和解读方面的信心有显著提高(两者p < 0.05),组间(分别为F(3,23) = 0.70,p = 无显著差异和F(3,23) = 0.32,p = 无显著差异)或不同带教老师的学生之间(两者p = 无显著差异)均无显著差异。PoCUS使用知识与信心的提高显著相关(r = 0.44,p < 0.05)。所有学生都表示喜欢教学课程的指导、内容和结构。教学课程最常被提及的优点是每个学生有强制性的个人实践时间、带教老师的个性化指导和互动以及课程的小组结构。
结论 本研究提供了新的证据,表明一个结构化的小组教学课程,包括理论讲授、明确的学习目标和强制性的实践学习,可以有效地向见习前学生传授PoCUS的入门知识和技能,并提高学生的信心。未来的研究将调查在整个临床实习和早期住院医师培训期间PoCUS知识和技能的保留和应用,以确定这种教学模式是否能够促进PoCUS的长期学习和能力提升,以及随着学生在本科医学培训中的进步,是否能提高诊断能力。