Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Ottawa, 540 King Edward Avenue, Ottawa, ON, K1N 6N5, Canada.
Ottawa Hospital Research Institute, 501 Smyth Road, Ottawa, ON, K1H 8L6, Canada.
Implement Sci. 2019 Jan 18;14(1):7. doi: 10.1186/s13012-018-0851-5.
BACKGROUND: Shared decision-making (SDM) is rarely implemented in pediatric practice. Pediatric health decision-making differs from that of adult practice. Yet, little is known about the factors that influence the implementation of pediatric shared decision-making (SDM). We synthesized pediatric SDM barriers and facilitators from the perspectives of healthcare providers (HCP), parents, children, and observers (i.e., persons who evaluated the SDM process, but were not directly involved). METHODS: We conducted a systematic review guided by the Ottawa Model of Research Use (OMRU). We searched MEDLINE, EMBASE, Cochrane Library, CINAHL, PubMed, and PsycINFO (inception to March 2017) and included studies that reported clinical pediatric SDM barriers and/or facilitators from the perspective of HCPs, parents, children, and/or observers. We considered all or no comparison groups and included all study designs reporting original data. Content analysis was used to synthesize barriers and facilitators and categorized them according to the OMRU levels (i.e., decision, innovation, adopters, relational, and environment) and participant types (i.e., HCP, parents, children, and observers). We used the Mixed Methods Appraisal Tool to appraise study quality. RESULTS: Of 20,008 identified citations, 79 were included. At each OMRU level, the most frequent barriers were features of the options (decision), poor quality information (innovation), parent/child emotional state (adopter), power relations (relational), and insufficient time (environment). The most frequent facilitators were low stake decisions (decision), good quality information (innovation), agreement with SDM (adopter), trust and respect (relational), and SDM tools/resources (environment). Across participant types, the most frequent barriers were insufficient time (HCPs), features of the options (parents), power imbalances (children), and HCP skill for SDM (observers). The most frequent facilitators were good quality information (HCP) and agreement with SDM (parents and children). There was no consistent facilitator category for observers. Overall, study quality was moderate with quantitative studies having the highest ratings and mixed-method studies having the lowest ratings. CONCLUSIONS: Numerous diverse and interrelated factors influence SDM use in pediatric clinical practice. Our findings can be used to identify potential pediatric SDM barriers and facilitators, guide context-specific barrier and facilitator assessments, and inform interventions for implementing SDM in pediatric practice. TRIAL REGISTRATION: PROSPERO CRD42015020527.
背景:共享决策(SDM)在儿科实践中很少实施。儿科健康决策与成人实践不同。然而,人们对影响儿科共享决策(SDM)实施的因素知之甚少。我们从医疗保健提供者(HCP)、父母、儿童和观察者(即评估 SDM 过程但未直接参与的人员)的角度综合了儿科 SDM 的障碍和促进因素。
方法:我们在渥太华研究使用模型(OMRU)的指导下进行了系统评价。我们检索了 MEDLINE、EMBASE、Cochrane 图书馆、CINAHL、PubMed 和 PsycINFO(从开始到 2017 年 3 月),并纳入了从 HCP、父母、儿童和/或观察者的角度报告临床儿科 SDM 障碍和/或促进因素的研究。我们考虑了所有或没有比较组,并纳入了报告原始数据的所有研究设计。内容分析用于综合障碍和促进因素,并根据 OMRU 水平(即决策、创新、采用者、关系和环境)和参与者类型(即 HCP、父母、儿童和观察者)对其进行分类。我们使用混合方法评估工具来评估研究质量。
结果:在 20,008 条鉴定的引文,有 79 条被纳入。在每个 OMRU 水平上,最常见的障碍是选项的特征(决策)、信息质量差(创新)、父母/孩子的情绪状态(采用者)、权力关系(关系)和时间不足(环境)。最常见的促进因素是低风险决策(决策)、高质量信息(创新)、对 SDM 的一致意见(采用者)、信任和尊重(关系)以及 SDM 工具/资源(环境)。在参与者类型中,最常见的障碍是时间不足(HCP)、选项的特征(父母)、权力失衡(儿童)和 HCP 进行 SDM 的技能(观察者)。最常见的促进因素是高质量的信息(HCP)和对 SDM 的一致意见(父母和孩子)。对于观察者来说,没有一致的促进因素类别。总的来说,研究质量为中等,定量研究的评分最高,混合方法研究的评分最低。
结论:许多不同且相互关联的因素影响儿科临床实践中的 SDM 使用。我们的研究结果可以用于确定潜在的儿科 SDM 障碍和促进因素,指导特定于上下文的障碍和促进因素评估,并为在儿科实践中实施 SDM 提供信息。
试验注册:PROSPERO CRD42015020527。
Implement Sci. 2019-1-18
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2016-11-29
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2013-6-6
Health Care Transit. 2025-6-12
Front Psychiatry. 2025-6-9
Child Care Health Dev. 2025
Can Fam Physician. 2017-9
Z Evid Fortbild Qual Gesundhwes. 2017-6
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2017-4-12
Health Promot Int. 2018-8-1
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2016-11-29