OsloMet - Oslo Metropolitan University (former Oslo and Akershus University College of Applied Sciences), Department of Nursing and Health Promotion, St. Olavs plass pb 4, 0130 Oslo, Norway.
Faculty of Nursing and Health Sciences, Nord University, 8049 Bodø, Norway.
Nurse Educ Pract. 2019 Feb;35:32-41. doi: 10.1016/j.nepr.2018.11.013. Epub 2018 Dec 3.
The aim of this review was to explore the evidence of learning from reflective writing in undergraduate clinical nursing education. A combination of 17 quantitative and qualitative studies were included and three main categories emerged Development of clinical reasoning skills, Professional self-development and Facilitators and barriers for learning. The results revealed that reflective writing enhanced the students' reasoning skills and awareness in clinical situations. However, most students reflected primarily at a descriptive level, showing only limited and varied development of reflective skills. They focused on self-assessment; on their own emotional reactions and ability to cope in clinical situations, but had difficulties reflecting on the process of thinking and learning. Learning was promoted through instructive guidelines, scaffolding and detailed feedback from a trusted, available and qualified faculty teacher. Factors that facilitated learning included student maturity, individual cognitive skills, student collaboration and mixed tools for learning. Time constraints, conflicting values, lack of feedback and support, and lack of trust acted as barriers for learning. Reflective writing is a tool for students' professional learning, but above all for the students' personal development in becoming a professional nurse.
本次综述旨在探讨在本科临床护理教育中,从反思性写作中学习的证据。共纳入了 17 项定量和定性研究,得出了三个主要类别:临床推理技能的发展、专业自我发展以及促进和阻碍学习的因素。研究结果表明,反思性写作提高了学生在临床环境中的推理技能和意识。然而,大多数学生主要处于描述性水平,仅表现出有限且多样化的反思技能发展。他们关注自我评估、自己在临床情况下的情绪反应和应对能力,但在思考和学习过程方面的反思能力存在困难。通过有指导意义的准则、支架和来自可信赖、可用且合格的教师的详细反馈,可以促进学习。促进学习的因素包括学生的成熟度、个体认知技能、学生合作以及混合学习工具。时间限制、价值观冲突、缺乏反馈和支持以及缺乏信任是学习的障碍。反思性写作是学生专业学习的工具,但更重要的是,它是学生成为专业护士的个人发展的工具。