Harris Barbara A, Panozzo Gina
DePaul University, United States.
DePaul University, United States; Benedictine University, United States; Chamberlain University, United States.
Arch Psychiatr Nurs. 2019 Feb;33(1):104-111. doi: 10.1016/j.apnu.2018.08.003. Epub 2018 Aug 8.
Schizophrenia is a chronic mental illness that affects the client, family, and community. Nurses are educated to use the nurse-patient relationship to provide health education and collaborative health decision-making. However, challenges abound for nurses and clients with schizophrenia to effectively utilize the relationship to reach these goals.
There is a lack of evidence-based information to assist nurses to meet the challenges of building effective therapeutic relationships with clients for whom schizophrenia hinders health education and decision-making.
To examine current research findings on factors that influence therapeutic relationships in psychiatric treatment settings as an initial effort to provide empirically based guidance for psychiatric nurses who seek to better use the relationship to work with the client toward health-related goals.
This integrative review of the literature follows Whittemore and Knafl's (2015) method, analyzes 15 studies from multiple databases between the years 2006-2017, and assesses the rigor of each.
Numerous methods are used to assess therapeutic relationships. Few studies included nurses. Provider perception of client symptoms can negatively affect provider assessment of quality of relationship; no such association was found on the part of clients. Providers and clients prioritize client needs differently, with providers influenced by treatment setting demands, but provider-training programs can have a beneficial effect on their relationships.
Nurses and nurse educators can use the findings to guide assessment of how perceptions and priorities influence relationships. Findings also provide the foundation for further study of nurses' perceptions of therapeutic relationship, in progress, to yield more detailed information on what nurses and educators need to strengthen therapeutic relationships.
精神分裂症是一种影响患者、家庭和社区的慢性精神疾病。护士接受教育,利用护患关系提供健康教育并共同做出健康决策。然而,对于护士和精神分裂症患者而言,要有效利用这种关系来实现这些目标,挑战众多。
缺乏基于证据的信息来帮助护士应对与精神分裂症患者建立有效治疗关系的挑战,因为精神分裂症会妨碍健康教育和决策。
审视当前关于影响精神科治疗环境中治疗关系的因素的研究结果,作为初步努力,为寻求更好地利用这种关系与患者朝着健康相关目标努力的精神科护士提供基于实证的指导。
本综合文献综述遵循惠特莫尔和克纳夫(2015年)的方法,分析了2006年至2017年间多个数据库中的15项研究,并评估了每项研究的严谨性。
有多种方法用于评估治疗关系。很少有研究纳入护士。提供者对患者症状的认知会对提供者对关系质量的评估产生负面影响;而患者方面未发现此类关联。提供者和患者对患者需求的优先级排列不同,提供者受治疗环境需求的影响,但提供者培训项目可对他们的关系产生有益影响。
护士和护士教育工作者可利用这些结果来指导评估认知和优先级如何影响关系。研究结果还为正在进行的关于护士对治疗关系的认知的进一步研究奠定了基础,以便得出关于护士和教育工作者加强治疗关系所需内容的更详细信息。