COBIN Project, Nepal Development Society, Bharatpur-10, Narayani Zone, Chitwan, Nepal.
Research Unit INSIDE, University of Luxembourg, Porte des Sciences L Esch-sur-Alzette, Luxembourg.
Health Policy Plan. 2019 Feb 1;34(1):55-66. doi: 10.1093/heapol/czy099.
The use of community health workers (CHWs) has been explored as a viable option to provide home health education, counselling and basic health care, notwithstanding their challenges in training and retention. In this manuscript, we review the evidence and discuss how the digitalization affects the CHWs programmes for tackling non-communicable diseases (NCDs) in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). We conducted a review of literature covering two databases: PubMED and Embase. A total of 97 articles were abstracted for full text review of which 26 are included in the analysis. Existing theories were used to construct a conceptual framework for understanding how digitalization affects the prospects of CHW programmes for NCDs. The results are divided into two themes: (1) the benefits of digitalization and (2) the challenges to the prospects of digitalization. We also conducted supplemental search in non-peer reviewed literature to identify and map the digital platforms currently in use in CHW programmes. We identified three benefits and three challenges of digitalization. Firstly, it will help improve the access and quality of services, notwithstanding its higher establishment and maintenance costs. Secondly, it will add efficiency in training and personnel management. Thirdly, it will leverage the use of data generated across grass-roots platforms to further research and evaluation. The challenges posed are related to funding, health literacy of CHWs and systemic challenges related to motivating CHWs. Several dozens of digital platforms were mapped, including mobile-based networking devices (used for behavioural change communication), Web-applications (used for contact tracking, reminder system, adherence tracing, data collection and decision support), videoconference (used for decision support) and mobile applications (used for reminder system, supervision, patients' management, hearing screening and tele-consultation). The digitalization efforts of CHW programmes are afflicted by many challenges, yet the rapid technological penetration and acceptability coupled with the gradual fall in costs constitute encouraging signals for the LMICs. Both CHWs interventions and digital technologies are not inexpensive, but they may provide better value for the money when applied at the right place and time.
使用社区卫生工作者(CHWs)提供家庭健康教育、咨询和基本医疗保健已被探索为一种可行的选择,尽管他们在培训和留用方面存在挑战。在本文中,我们回顾了证据,并讨论了数字化如何影响中低收入国家(LMICs)针对非传染性疾病(NCDs)的 CHW 计划。我们对涵盖两个数据库的文献进行了综述:PubMED 和 Embase。共提取了 97 篇文章进行全文审查,其中 26 篇纳入分析。现有理论被用于构建一个概念框架,以理解数字化如何影响 CHW 计划针对 NCD 的前景。结果分为两个主题:(1)数字化的好处,(2)数字化前景的挑战。我们还在非同行评审文献中进行了补充搜索,以确定和绘制 CHW 计划中当前使用的数字平台。我们确定了数字化的三个好处和三个挑战。首先,它将有助于改善服务的可及性和质量,尽管其建立和维护成本更高。其次,它将提高培训和人员管理的效率。第三,它将利用基层平台生成的数据来促进研究和评估。面临的挑战与资金、CHWs 的健康素养以及与激励 CHWs 相关的系统挑战有关。数十个数字平台被绘制,包括基于移动的联网设备(用于行为改变沟通)、Web 应用程序(用于联系跟踪、提醒系统、依从性跟踪、数据收集和决策支持)、视频会议(用于决策支持)和移动应用程序(用于提醒系统、监督、患者管理、听力筛查和远程咨询)。CHW 计划的数字化工作受到许多挑战的困扰,但快速的技术渗透和可接受性,加上成本的逐渐下降,对 LMICs 构成了令人鼓舞的信号。CHW 干预措施和数字技术都不便宜,但如果在正确的地点和时间使用,它们可能会提供更好的性价比。