Department of Radiology, Seoul National University Hospital, Seoul, Korea.
Department of Radiology, Seoul National University College of Medicine, Seoul, Korea.
Korean J Radiol. 2019 Feb;20(2):283-294. doi: 10.3348/kjr.2017.0507.
To compare quantitative and qualitative image quality parameters in pediatric abdominopelvic dual-energy CT (DECT) using noise-optimized virtual monoenergetic image (VMI) and conventional VMI at different kiloelectron volt (keV) levels.
Thirty-six consecutive abdominopelvic DECT scans were retrospectively included. Noise-optimized VMI and conventional VMI were reconstructed at seven energy levels, from 40 keV to 100 keV at 10 keV intervals. The contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) and signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of the liver, pancreas, and aorta were objectively measured and compared. Image quality was evaluated subjectively regarding image noise, image blurring of solid organ, bowel image quality and severity of beam-hardening artifacts. Optimal monoenergetic levels in keV for both algorithms were determined based on overall image quality score.
The maximal CNR and SNR values for all investigated organs were observed at 40 keV in noise-optimized VMI (CNR and SNR of liver, pancreas, aorta in order [CNR; 20.93, 17.34, 46.75: SNR; 37.39, 33.80, 63.21]), at 60-70 keV and at 70 keV in conventional VMI (CNR; 8.12, 5.67, 15.97: SNR; 19.57, 16.66, 26.65). In qualitative image analysis, noise-optimized VMI and conventional VMI showed the best overall image quality scores at 60 keV and at 70 keV, respectively. Noise-optimized VMI at 60 keV showed superior CNRs, SNRs, and overall image quality scores compared to conventional VMI at 70 keV ( < 0.001).
Optimal energy levels for noise-optimized VMI and conventional VMI were 60 keV and at 70 keV, respectively. Noise-optimized VMI shows superior CNRs, SNRs and subjective image quality over conventional VMI, at the optimal energy level.
比较儿童腹部盆腔双能 CT(DECT)中使用噪声优化虚拟单能量图像(VMI)和不同千伏(keV)水平下常规 VMI 的定量和定性图像质量参数。
回顾性纳入 36 例连续腹部盆腔 DECT 扫描。在七个能量水平上重建噪声优化的 VMI 和常规 VMI,从 40 keV 到 100 keV,每隔 10 keV 一次。客观测量并比较肝脏、胰腺和主动脉的对比噪声比(CNR)和信噪比(SNR)。主观评估图像噪声、实体器官图像模糊、肠管图像质量和束硬化伪影严重程度,评价图像质量。根据总体图像质量评分,确定两种算法的最佳单能量水平。
在噪声优化的 VMI 中,所有受检器官的最大 CNR 和 SNR 值均出现在 40 keV(肝脏、胰腺、主动脉的 CNR 和 SNR 按顺序排列[CNR;20.93、17.34、46.75:SNR;37.39、33.80、63.21]),在常规 VMI 中,在 60-70 keV 和 70 keV 处(CNR;8.12、5.67、15.97:SNR;19.57、16.66、26.65)。在定性图像分析中,噪声优化的 VMI 和常规 VMI 分别在 60 keV 和 70 keV 时获得最佳总体图像质量评分。与常规 VMI 在 70 keV 时相比,噪声优化的 VMI 在 60 keV 时显示出更高的 CNR、SNR 和总体图像质量评分(<0.001)。
噪声优化的 VMI 和常规 VMI 的最佳能量水平分别为 60 keV 和 70 keV。在最佳能量水平下,噪声优化的 VMI 比常规 VMI 具有更高的 CNR、SNR 和主观图像质量。