Department of Environmental Landscape Architecture, Gangneung-Wonju National University, Gangneung, South Korea.
Research Department, Site Planning Co. Ltd, 157, UN-ro, Nam-gu, Busan, 48505, South Korea.
Environ Sci Pollut Res Int. 2019 Mar;26(8):8007-8018. doi: 10.1007/s11356-019-04272-5. Epub 2019 Jan 25.
How do local community perceive pollution risk and social problems in abandoned areas? Which factors affect these risk perceptions? Among several factors affecting environmental perceptions, familiarity to places has long been known to positively affect landscape perception, but is this also true for abandoned area with scruffy vegetation and industrial remnants? Will long-term residents eventually adapt to and accept these neglected landscapes? In the past, efforts have largely been devoted to the cleanup of large, highly polluted areas. This left many smaller, less polluted sites, often in urban or suburban areas, relatively neglected. These areas, which typically consist of small abandoned industrial and commercial sites and vacant lots in neighborhoods, are problematic since people living nearby continue to suffer from urban blight. Recently, there has been a shift in the focus of brownfield programs from highly polluted post-industrial cleanup to local brownfield reuse. In this new environment, a participatory planning process that engages the community seems to have become more important. In order to better understand factors affecting community people's risk perception and effectively engage community support for the better management of derelict sites, this study investigated the factors on local community perceptions of abandoned landscapes including the effect of familiarity (the length of residency) and other sociodemographic (gender and age). For the study, the 200 study participants in eight neighborhoods along the Rail Corridor Revitalization Project in the city of Roanoke, VA, were asked to participate in survey and evaluate scenes of three types of abandoned landscapes focusing on two aspects, preference and pollution concerns. The results of scene ratings showed that lower scene preferences were associated with scene concerns related to higher pollution. However, although age and gender were associated with participants' preference ratings and attitudes toward social problems and pollution, there was no significant effect for the length of residency.
当地社区如何看待废弃区域的污染风险和社会问题?哪些因素会影响这些风险认知?在影响环境认知的诸多因素中,人们对环境的熟悉程度早已被证实会对景观认知产生积极影响,但对于植被杂乱、留有工业遗迹的废弃区域是否也是如此呢?长期居住在此的居民最终是否会适应并接受这些被忽视的景观?过去,人们的努力主要集中在清理大型、高度污染的区域。这导致许多较小、污染程度较低的场地被相对忽视,这些场地通常位于城市或郊区,由小型废弃的工业和商业场地以及社区内的空地组成,因为居住在附近的人们仍在遭受城市衰败的困扰。最近,棕地计划的重点已经从高度污染的后工业清理转向了当地棕地再利用。在这种新环境下,参与式规划过程似乎变得更加重要,它可以吸引社区参与。为了更好地了解影响社区居民风险认知的因素,并有效地争取社区支持,以更好地管理废弃场地,本研究调查了影响当地社区对废弃景观认知的因素,包括熟悉程度(居住时间长短)和其他社会人口因素(性别和年龄)。在这项研究中,弗吉尼亚州罗阿诺克市铁路走廊复兴项目沿线的八个社区的 200 名研究参与者被要求参与调查并对三种类型的废弃景观场景进行评估,重点关注两个方面,即偏好和污染问题。场景评分的结果表明,较低的场景偏好与与更高污染相关的场景问题有关。然而,尽管年龄和性别与参与者对社会问题和污染的偏好评分和态度有关,但居住时间长短并没有显著影响。