Kumar V Dinesh
Department of Anatomy, Jawaharlal Institute of Postgraduate Medical Education and Research, Puducherry, India.
J Adv Med Educ Prof. 2019 Jan;7(1):42-46. doi: 10.30476/JAMP.2019.41035.
Medical education requires participation of various stakeholders and this contributes to power dynamics operating at multiple levels. Personality traits of an individual can affect the smooth execution of the educational programmes and eventually the professionalism of the environment. With the increased focus on leadership traits in medical education and collaboration in health care settings, I, through this commentary, would like to explore the Machiavellian power dynamics involved and how it can influence the harmony prevailing in an organization.
The author has tried to review the several aspects of Machiavellianism in health care settings and describe day-to-day experiences at four levels; micro (individual), meso (departmental), macro (institutional) and mega (discipline). Introspecting on the unaddressed issues in a different light would help to gain a deeper understanding regarding work place ethics and professionalism.
The reflection of day-to-day experiences in a different perspective would provide an insight regarding various issues to health professionals and help in developing ethical leadership abilities in them, which eventually promulgates professionalism.
To my best knowledge, this is the first commentary to deal with the implications of Machiavellianism in different issues related to health care settings. With the increased emphasis on the leadership traits related to medical education, analysing organizational issues in various dimensions is of paramount importance.
医学教育需要各类利益相关者的参与,这导致了多层次的权力动态。个体的人格特质会影响教育项目的顺利实施,并最终影响环境的专业性。随着医学教育中对领导特质和医疗保健环境中协作的关注度不断提高,我想通过这篇评论探讨其中涉及的马基雅维利式权力动态,以及它如何影响组织中普遍存在的和谐。
作者试图回顾医疗保健环境中马基雅维利主义的几个方面,并描述微观(个体)、中观(部门)、宏观(机构)和巨型(学科)四个层面的日常经历。从不同角度审视未解决的问题将有助于更深入地理解职场伦理和专业性。
从不同角度反思日常经历将为卫生专业人员提供有关各种问题的见解,并有助于培养他们的道德领导能力,最终促进专业性。
据我所知,这是第一篇探讨马基雅维利主义在与医疗保健环境相关的不同问题中的影响的评论。随着对与医学教育相关的领导特质的强调增加,从各个维度分析组织问题至关重要。