CSIRO, Agriculture and Food, Locked Bag 1, Armidale NSW, Australia.
School of Agriculture and Environment and the University of Western Australia Institute of Agriculture, The University of Western Australia, Crawley WA, Australia.
PLoS One. 2019 Jan 30;14(1):e0211363. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0211363. eCollection 2019.
Environmental challenges are part of everyday life for most domestic animals. However, very little is known about how animals cope emotionally and physiologically with cumulative challenges. This experiment aimed to determine the impact of long-term exposure to environmental challenges on the affective state and hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal (HPA) axis responses to a subsequent additional acute shearing challenge.
Sheep were exposed to either a long-term environmental challenge (rest disruption and individual housing) in order to induce chronic stress (chronic stress group) or control conditions (group housing in a field with low stress handling and daily feed rewards, control group). Judgement and attention bias were assessed as measures of the emotional state following several days of the challenge or control treatment (pre-shearing tests). In addition, the responsiveness of the HPA-axis was evaluated using a combined Corticotropin Releasing Hormone and Arginine Vasopressin (CRH/AVP) challenge. Finally, all animals were exposed to an acute shearing challenge, then judgement bias (post-shearing test), HPA-axis and internal body temperature responses were determined.
In the pre-shearing judgement bias test, the chronic stress group slightly increased optimism compared to the control treatment. In the attention bias test, the chronic stress group showed reduced vigilance behaviour towards a predator threat and a quicker approach to the food compared to the control treatment. The chronic stress group also had lower plasma ACTH concentrations in response to the CRH/AVP challenge compared to the control group, no differences in cortisol concentrations were found. In the post-shearing judgement bias test, differences in optimism were no longer evident between the chronic stress and control groups. Plasma ACTH concentrations and body temperatures showed a greater increase in response to shearing in the chronic stress group compared to the control group.
Our results suggest that long-term exposure to challenges biased cognitive measures of the affective state towards an increased expectation of a reward and reduced attention towards a threat. The exaggerated ACTH responses in the chronic stress group may be indicative of HPA-axis dysregulation. Despite a period of challenge exposure in the chronic stress group, judgement bias responses to the shearing challenge were similar in the chronic stress and control groups; the reasons for this need further investigation. The altered affective state together with signs of HPA-axis dysregulation may indicate an increased risk of compromised welfare in animals exposed to long-term environmental challenges.
环境挑战是大多数家养动物日常生活的一部分。然而,对于动物如何在情感和生理上应对累积的挑战,人们知之甚少。本实验旨在确定长期暴露于环境挑战对随后的急性剪毛挑战的情绪状态和下丘脑-垂体-肾上腺(HPA)轴反应的影响。
将绵羊暴露于长期环境挑战(扰乱休息和单独饲养)以诱导慢性应激(慢性应激组)或对照条件(在低应激处理和每日饲料奖励的野外群养,对照组)。判断和注意力偏差作为挑战或对照处理数天后情绪状态的测量(剪毛前测试)。此外,使用促肾上腺皮质激素释放激素和精氨酸加压素(CRH/AVP)联合挑战评估 HPA 轴的反应性。最后,所有动物都受到急性剪毛挑战的影响,然后确定判断偏差(剪毛后测试)、HPA 轴和内部体温反应。
在剪毛前的判断偏差测试中,慢性应激组与对照组相比,略微增加了乐观情绪。在注意力偏差测试中,慢性应激组对捕食者威胁的警觉性降低,对食物的接近速度加快,与对照组相比。与对照组相比,慢性应激组在 CRH/AVP 挑战中 ACTH 浓度较低,皮质醇浓度无差异。在剪毛后的判断偏差测试中,慢性应激组和对照组之间的乐观情绪差异不再明显。与对照组相比,慢性应激组对剪毛的反应中 ACTH 浓度和体温升高幅度更大。
我们的结果表明,长期暴露于挑战会使认知状态的情感状态向增加奖励预期和减少对威胁的关注倾斜。慢性应激组的 ACTH 反应过度可能表明 HPA 轴失调。尽管慢性应激组经历了一段时间的挑战暴露,但慢性应激组和对照组对剪毛挑战的判断偏差反应相似;需要进一步调查这种情况的原因。改变的情感状态加上 HPA 轴失调的迹象可能表明长期暴露于环境挑战的动物的福利受到损害的风险增加。