AP-HP, Pôle de Psychiatrie des Hôpitaux Universitaires H Mondor, Créteil, F94000, France.
INSERM, U955, Equipe 15 Psychiatrie translationnelle, Créteil, F94000, France.
Sci Rep. 2019 Feb 4;9(1):1294. doi: 10.1038/s41598-018-37484-9.
Current medical research has focused on diseases and their associated risk factors. As such, these factors are assumed to have a deleterious effect. An alternative hypothesis is that some of these risk factors would also increase the chance for an opposite, positive outcome. To test this hypothesis, we considered exceptional social achievement and schizophrenia as opposite outcomes. Sixty years ago, researchers in France collected data on socio-demographic factors associated with exceptional social achievement. As the number of female subjects in the original database was very limited, we restricted our analyses to men. We tested the odds of achieving prominence in the presence of factors known to be associated with an increased risk of schizophrenia, namely migration, urbanicity, seasonality of birth, birth order, and paternal age. Three of the five factors tested significantly increased the odds for exceptional social achievement (urban birth, being the first-born and father's age over 35). Our findings suggest that some of the factors that are currently considered as risk factors for schizophrenia could diversifying factors. Widening the focus of research to include all potential effects of factors associated with disease could have important consequences on our understanding of causal mechanisms and for designing public health interventions.
当前的医学研究主要集中在疾病及其相关的风险因素上。因此,这些因素被认为具有有害的影响。另一种假设是,这些风险因素中的一些也会增加相反的积极结果的机会。为了检验这一假设,我们将非凡的社会成就和精神分裂症视为相反的结果。60 年前,法国的研究人员收集了与非凡社会成就相关的社会人口因素的数据。由于原始数据库中女性受试者的数量非常有限,我们将分析仅限于男性。我们测试了在已知与精神分裂症风险增加相关的因素存在的情况下,取得突出成就的几率,即移民、城市化、出生季节、出生顺序和父亲年龄。在测试的五个因素中有三个显著增加了非凡社会成就的几率(城市出生、长子和父亲年龄超过 35 岁)。我们的研究结果表明,目前被认为是精神分裂症风险因素的一些因素可能是多样化因素。将研究的重点扩大到包括与疾病相关的因素的所有潜在影响,可能会对我们理解因果机制和设计公共卫生干预措施产生重要影响。