University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
The Dauten Family Center for Bipolar Treatment Innovation, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts.
Bipolar Disord. 2019 Aug;21(5):428-436. doi: 10.1111/bdi.12752. Epub 2019 Feb 27.
Lithium and quetiapine are known to be effective treatments for bipolar disorder. However, little information is available to inform prediction of response to these medications. Machine-learning methods can identify predictors of response by examining variables simultaneously. Further evaluation of models on a test sample can estimate how well these models would generalize to other samples.
Data (N = 482) were drawn from a randomized clinical trial of outpatients with bipolar I or II disorder who received adjunctive personalized treatment plus either lithium or quetiapine. Elastic net regularization (ENR) was used to generate models for lithium and quetiapine; these models were evaluated on a test set.
Predictions from the lithium model explained 17.4% of the variance in actual observed scores of patients who received lithium in the test set, while predictions from the quetiapine model explained 32.1% of the variance of patients that received quetiapine. Of the baseline variables selected, those with the largest parameter estimates were: severity of mania; attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) comorbidity; nonsuicidal self-injurious behavior; employment; and comorbidity with each of two anxiety disorders (social phobia/society anxiety and agoraphobia). Predictive accuracy of the ENR model outperformed the simple and basic theoretical models.
ENR is an effective approach for building optimal and generalizable models. Variables identified through this methodology can inform future research on predictors of response to lithium and quetiapine, as well as future modeling efforts of treatment choice in bipolar disorder.
锂和喹硫平已被证实是治疗双相情感障碍的有效方法。然而,关于这些药物的反应预测,可用的信息有限。机器学习方法可以通过同时检查变量来识别反应的预测因子。在测试样本上进一步评估模型可以估计这些模型对其他样本的泛化程度。
数据(N=482)取自一项双相 I 或 II 障碍门诊患者的随机临床试验,这些患者接受附加的个体化治疗,加用锂或喹硫平。弹性网络正则化(ENR)用于生成锂和喹硫平的模型;这些模型在测试集上进行了评估。
锂模型的预测解释了测试集中接受锂治疗的患者实际观察得分的 17.4%的方差,而喹硫平模型的预测解释了接受喹硫平治疗的患者的 32.1%的方差。在所选择的基线变量中,参数估计值最大的是:躁狂严重程度;注意力缺陷/多动障碍(ADHD)共病;非自杀性自伤行为;就业;以及两种焦虑障碍(社交恐惧症/社会焦虑和广场恐怖症)中的每一种的共病。ENR 模型的预测准确性优于简单和基本的理论模型。
ENR 是一种构建最优和可泛化模型的有效方法。通过该方法确定的变量可以为锂和喹硫平反应预测的未来研究以及双相情感障碍治疗选择的未来建模工作提供信息。