Bolton D A E, Buick A R, Carroll T J, Carson R G
Department of Kinesiology and Health Sciences, Utah State University, Logan, USA.
School of Psychology, Queen's University Belfast, Belfast, UK.
Exp Brain Res. 2019 Apr;237(4):1077-1092. doi: 10.1007/s00221-019-05484-4. Epub 2019 Feb 13.
Transfer, in which capability acquired in one situation influences performance in another is considered, along with retention, as demonstrative of effectual learning. In this regard, interlimb transfer of functional capacity has commanded particular attention as a means of gauging the generalisation of acquired capability. Both theoretical treatments and prior empirical studies suggest that the successful accomplishment of a physical training regime is required to bring about generalised changes that extend to the untrained limb. In the present study, we pose the following question: Does interlimb transfer occur if and only if the training movements are executed? We report findings from JG-an individual recruited to a larger scale trial, who presented with (unilateral) deficits of motor control. We examined whether changes in the performance of the untrained right limb arose following practice undertaken by the impaired left limb, wherein the majority of JG's attempts to execute the training task were unsuccessful. Comparison was made with a group of "control" participants drawn from the main trial, who did not practice the task. For JG, substantial gains in the performance of the untrained limb (registered 3 days, 10 days and 1 year following training) indicated that effective learning had occurred. Learning was, however, expressed principally when the unimpaired (i.e. untrained) limb was utilised to perform the task. When the impaired limb was used, marked deficiencies in movement execution remained prominent throughout.
迁移,即在一种情境中获得的能力会影响在另一种情境中的表现,与保持一样,被视为有效学习的证明。在这方面,功能能力的肢体间迁移作为衡量获得能力泛化的一种手段,受到了特别关注。理论论述和先前的实证研究均表明,要实现扩展到未训练肢体的泛化变化,需要成功完成体能训练方案。在本研究中,我们提出以下问题:肢体间迁移是否仅在训练动作被执行时才会发生?我们报告了来自JG的研究结果,JG是一名被招募到一个更大规模试验中的个体,其存在(单侧)运动控制缺陷。我们研究了在受损的左肢进行练习后,未训练的右肢的表现是否发生了变化,其中JG执行训练任务的大多数尝试都未成功。我们将其与从主要试验中抽取的一组“对照”参与者进行了比较,这些对照参与者没有练习该任务。对于JG来说,未训练肢体的表现有显著提高(在训练后3天、10天和1年进行记录),这表明发生了有效的学习。然而,学习主要表现在使用未受损(即未训练)的肢体执行任务时。当使用受损肢体时,整个运动执行过程中明显的缺陷仍然很突出。