Lau Sin Hang, Huang Yaqian, Ferreira Victor S, Vul Edward
Department of Psychology, University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, CA, USA.
Department of Linguistics, University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, CA, USA.
Atten Percept Psychophys. 2019 May;81(4):1076-1087. doi: 10.3758/s13414-019-01682-y.
The relationships between word frequency and various perceptual features have been used to study the cognitive processes involved in word production and recognition, as well as patterns in language use over time. However, little work has been done comparing spoken and written frequencies against each other, which leaves open the question of whether there are modality-specific relationships between perceptual features and frequency. Words have different frequencies in speech and written texts, with some words occurring disproportionately more often in one modality than the other. In the present study, we investigated whether perceptual features predict this frequency asymmetry across modalities. Our results suggest that perceptual features such as length, neighborhood density, and positional probability differentially affect speech and writing, which reveals different online processing constraints and considerations for communicative efficiency across the two modalities. These modality-specific effects exist above and beyond formality differences. This work provides arguments against theories that assume that words differing in frequency are perceptually equivalent, as well as models that predict little to no influence of perceptual features on top-down processes of word selection.
词频与各种感知特征之间的关系已被用于研究单词生成和识别过程中涉及的认知过程,以及语言使用随时间的模式。然而,很少有研究将口语频率和书面频率相互比较,这就留下了一个问题:感知特征与频率之间是否存在特定模态的关系。单词在口语和书面文本中的频率不同,有些单词在一种模态中出现的频率比另一种模态中高得多。在本研究中,我们调查了感知特征是否能预测跨模态的这种频率不对称性。我们的结果表明,诸如长度、邻域密度和位置概率等感知特征对口语和书面语有不同的影响,这揭示了两种模态在在线处理约束和交际效率方面的不同考虑。这些特定模态的影响存在于形式差异之上。这项工作为那些假设频率不同的单词在感知上等效的理论,以及那些预测感知特征对单词选择的自上而下过程几乎没有影响的模型提供了反对论据。