Berry Ed D J, Allen Richard J, Waterman Amanda H, Logie Robert H
1 School of Psychology, University of Leeds, UK.
2 Department of Psychology, University of Edinburgh, UK.
Exp Psychol. 2019 Jan;66(1):77-85. doi: 10.1027/1618-3169/a000428.
By investigating the effect of individualized verbal load on a visual working memory task, we investigated whether working memory is better captured by modality-specific stores or a general attentional resource. A visual measure was used that allows for the precision of representations in working memory to be quantified. Bayesian analyses were employed to contrast the likelihood of our data assuming a small versus a large effect, as predicted by the differing accounts. We found evidence that the effect of verbal load on visual precision and binary feature recall was small. The results were indeterminate for the size of the dual task effect on verbal accuracy and the probability of recalling a continuous target feature. These results, in part, support a multiple component account of working memory. An analysis of how the chosen effect intervals affect the results is also reported, highlighting the importance of making specific predictions in the literature.
通过研究个性化言语负荷对视觉工作记忆任务的影响,我们探究了工作记忆是由特定模态存储还是一般注意力资源能更好地捕捉。我们使用了一种视觉测量方法,该方法能够对工作记忆中表征的精确性进行量化。采用贝叶斯分析来对比我们的数据在假设效应小与效应大的情况下的似然性,这是由不同理论预测的。我们发现有证据表明言语负荷对视觉精确性和二元特征回忆的影响较小。对于双重任务对言语准确性的影响大小以及回忆连续目标特征的概率,结果并不确定。这些结果部分支持了工作记忆的多成分理论。我们还报告了对所选效应区间如何影响结果的分析,强调了在文献中做出具体预测的重要性。